 | Gail Davis | ... | Annie Oakley (82 episodes, 1954-1999) |
 | Brad Johnson | ... | Deputy Sheriff Lofty Craig / ... (81 episodes, 1954-1957) |

| Jimmy Hawkins | ... | Tagg Oakley (80 episodes, 1953-1957) |
 | Bob Woodward | ... | Stagecoach Driver / ... (44 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Jack Tornek | ... | Townsman / ... (22 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Jack Perrin | ... | Townsman / ... (17 episodes, 1954-1956) |

| Dick Tufeld | | (15 episodes, 1954) |
 | Jimmy Noel | ... | Townsman / ... (13 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Herman Hack | ... | Townsman / ... (13 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Ray Jones | ... | Townsman / ... (13 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Harry Lauter | ... | Bert Slade / ... (12 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Stanley Andrews | ... | Chet Osgood / ... (11 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Gregg Barton | ... | Boyd Spencer / ... (11 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | 'Snub' Pollard | ... | Townsman / ... (11 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Myron Healey | ... | Al Proctor / ... (10 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Tex Palmer | ... | Townsman / ... (10 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Rick Vallin | ... | Al / ... (9 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Art Dillard | ... | Henchman / ... (9 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Walter Reed | ... | Arthur Berkeley / ... (8 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Roy Barcroft | ... | Carter Holmes / ... (8 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Sam Flint | ... | Banker Oliver / ... (8 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | William Henry | ... | Brick Mason / ... (8 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Lane Bradford | ... | Cash Naylor / ... (8 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | William Fawcett | ... | Assayer Sam Porter / ... (7 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Frankie Marvin | ... | Townsman / ... (7 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Frank Fenton | ... | Bragan / ... (6 episodes, 1956) |
 | Keith Richards | ... | Adam Scott / ... (6 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | William Tannen | ... | Al / ... (6 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Henry Rowland | ... | Calaveras / ... (6 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Terry Frost | ... | Butler / ... (6 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Paul E. Burns | ... | Clem Lacey / ... (6 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Tom London | ... | Buckhorn, Diablo Stage Manager / ... (5 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Don C. Harvey | ... | Cody Barnes / ... (5 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Kenne Duncan | ... | Dr. Sharpe / ... (5 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Jack Montgomery | ... | Townsman / ... (5 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Chick Hannan | ... | Townsman / ... (5 episodes, 1956) |
 | Tyler MacDuff | ... | Clement O'Toole / ... (4 episodes, 1956) |
 | Dickie Jones | ... | Bob Neil / ... (4 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | House Peters Jr. | ... | Lily Maid's Chief Henchman / ... (4 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | George J. Lewis | ... | Chief Angry Owl / ... (4 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Richard Reeves | ... | Billy Yancey / ... (4 episodes, 1954-1956) |

| Slim Pickens | ... | Ed Morgan / ... (4 episodes, 1956) |
 | Baynes Barron | ... | Al Jensen / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Charles Hayes | ... | Eddie Sloan / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Holly Bane | ... | Henchman / ... (4 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Nancy Hale | ... | Bess Murdock / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1957) |

| Helene Marshall | ... | Helen Bronson / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Robert Williams | ... | Percival Adams / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Harry Harvey | ... | Mayor Pearlson / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Steve Darrell | ... | Dan Bolton / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Ewing Mitchell | ... | Ab Forsyth / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Mickey Simpson | ... | Frank / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Edgar Dearing | ... | Big Jim Baldwin / ... (3 episodes, 1956) |
 | Duane Grey | ... | Frank Doyle / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Steve Pendleton | ... | Henchman Fowler / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Chris Alcaide | ... | Duke Jaegar / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | X Brands | ... | Peter Maher / ... (3 episodes, 1956) |
 | Eve Miller | ... | Jane Lester / ... (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Marshall Reed | ... | Al / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | William Phipps | ... | Dan Carter / ... (3 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Grace Field | ... | Bertha Davis / ... (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Glenn Strange | ... | Ernie Barker / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | John L. Cason | ... | Emmett / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Joe Haworth | ... | Mike Sawyer / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Stuffy Singer | ... | Billy Reynolds / ... (3 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Bud Osborne | ... | Dan / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Harry Mackin | ... | Bicycle Rider / ... (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Frank Ellis | ... | Townsman / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Signe Hack | ... | Townswoman (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Jack O'Shea | ... | Townsman / ... (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Leonard P. Geer | ... | Townsman / ... (3 episodes, 1956) |
 | Kirk Alyn | ... | Arthur Blodgett / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |

| James Best | ... | Jess Dugan / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Kenneth MacDonald | ... | Sheriff Luke MacTavish, Annie's Uncle / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Maura Murphy | ... | Elaine Forbes aka Lily Maid / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Robert Emmett O'Connor | ... | Ben Dodson / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Roscoe Ates | ... | Curly Dawes / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Robert Easton | ... | 'Smiley' Douglas / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Raymond Hatton | ... | Scissorbill Childers / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Leonard Penn | ... | Jeff Warren / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| John Doucette | ... | Duke Bailey / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |

| Alan Hale Jr. | ... | Eli Gorham / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Virginia Lee | ... | Lil Benton / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Fess Parker | ... | Les Clinton - The Texas Sandman / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Victor Millan | ... | Brave Rider / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Jean Howell | ... | Linda Warren / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Glase Lohman | ... | Martin Ellison / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Steven Clark | ... | Henchman Joe Barker / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Ron Hagerthy | ... | Billy Stryker / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Lili Kardell | ... | Elinor Denain / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Mary Ellen Kay | ... | Ellen Harkey / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Denver Pyle | ... | Dr. Barnes / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Carolyn Craig | ... | Della Forsyth / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Michael Garrett | ... | Dave Morgan / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Larry Chance | ... | Con Morley / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Christopher Cook | ... | Francis Kruger / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Donald Curtis | ... | Lee Tobey / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Gábor Curtiz | ... | Dr. Herrick / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Robert 'Buzz' Henry | ... | Cal Blane / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Arthur Space | ... | Carl Bishop / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Forrest Taylor | ... | Dr. Thomas Moody / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Joe Cranston | ... | Dave Warren / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Barry Curtis | ... | Billy Nelson / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Barry Froner | ... | Tim Crawford / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Mary Ellen Clemons | ... | Kathy Morgan / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Sally Fraser | ... | Nancy Cooper / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | John War Eagle | ... | Chief Thunder Cloud / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Carleton Young | ... | Colonel Jackson / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | John Beradino | ... | Gorman / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Robert Cabal | ... | Red Pony (2 episodes, 1956) |

| L.Q. Jones | ... | Cal Upton / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Bill Crandall | ... | Jim / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Karl 'Killer' Davis | ... | Charlie Bassett / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Douglas Grange | ... | Bill Yorty / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Hank Patterson | ... | Jake Wilkin / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1957) |
 | Al Bridge | ... | Pop Wade / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Edward Clark | ... | Hotel Clerk (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Frederick Ford | ... | Lou / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Francis McDonald | ... | Editor Bert Cooper / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Dick Elliott | ... | George Sykes / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1956) |
 | Joel Ashley | ... | Jack Dixon / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Melinda Plowman | ... | Jill Turner / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Harry Cheshire | ... | Judge Everard Bowen / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Gloria Jean | ... | Lucy Ann Barker / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Jim Bannon | ... | Ben Porter / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Lawrence Ryle | ... | Mr. Prince / ... (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Barbara Woodell | ... | Martha Peters / ... (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Douglas Kennedy | ... | Jim Hayward / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |

| Lee Van Cleef | ... | Amos Belcher / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |

| Lyle Talbot | ... | Colonel Dawson / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Boyd 'Red' Morgan | ... | Henchman Mears / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |

| James Griffith | ... | George Martin / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | David Alpert | ... | Fred Hutton / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Tom Monroe | ... | Bat Norris / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Marshall Bradford | ... | Dan Potter / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | John Damler | ... | Casco / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Monte Blue | ... | Mr. Peabody / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Dennis Moore | ... | Henchman Mike Edwards / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Jim Diehl | ... | Johnson / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Pierre Watkin | ... | Henry Lormier / ... (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Mike Taylor | ... | Horace Peabody Jr. / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Frank Richards | ... | Creede / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Carol Henry | ... | Ben Colton / ... (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Jack Low | ... | Townsman / ... (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Mathew McCue | ... | Townsman (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Clyde Howdy | ... | Townsman (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Eddie Dew | ... | Hap Hadley / ... (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Bill Coontz | ... | Miner / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |