The Great Diamond Robbery (1954) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A Film That Disappeared
theowinthrop28 October 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This was a nice film - an average comic adventure story and nothing more. At the time it was made it's star, Red Skelton was really concentrating on his very successful comedy variety show on television that would last until the 1970s. He still would make movies, but they were no longer an absolute necessity. Skelton was one of the first stars in Hollywood that realized that far from being a useful stop-gap for periods that you were not making films or on stage, television had a logic and rhythm of it's own that when studied and applied was just as good as the other mediums. He must have realized this from his years working on the similar, but somewhat limited medium of radio.

So this film, while amusing, would probably have been as good with anyone else playing Ambrose C. Park (the "C" is for "Central" - Ambrose was abandoned in Central Park) than Skelton. For example Danny Kaye might have tried it out and done well (possibly a musical number would have been added). But this means that the normal stunts and sight gags associated with Skelton's best films were not involved in this one (except one memorable last one that I will always recall fondly).

Interestingly enough, THE GREAT DIAMOND ROBBERY is very rarely shown on television anymore. I saw it in the early 1960s, when both Skelton and Cara Williams were prominent television stars. But memories of their work is not pushed these days (surprisingly so with Skelton, who left a surprisingly sturdy body of film work). So if you catch a chance to see it, watch it...you may not have a second chance quickly afterward.

Ambrose, a foundling, wants to find his real parents. He happens to be in an unusual profession - he is a highly skilled jewelry cutter. His second fondest wish is to tackle a peculiarly difficult jewel that has just been found. Potentially it is one of the great jewels, like the Culinor or the Hope Diamond, but it has to be cut just so to split in half. Otherwise it may as well be used in a road bed with gravel. So his bosses are arguing with him that he is not ready to do the diamond properly (despite his showing them charts he has drawn after studying it and it's flaws).

Ambrose is still searching for his parents, and while doing so meets an attorney Mr. Remlick (James Whitmore, in an early performance). Remlick is also interested in this diamond. He happens to be working with some thieves who want to steal it. So Remlick finds Ambrose fascinating as both searcher and as diamond cutter. Remlick and his backers led by Uncle Tony (Kurt Kazner) "help" Ambrose find his "mother" Mrs. Drumman (Dorothy Stickney) and his "sister" Maggie (Cara Williams). He is very happy about this situation, except he and Maggie find themselves looking at each other in non-sibling terms. That is becoming uncomfortable for both of them.

The rest of the film follows the way the gang manipulate Ambrose into taking the jewel home to cut, to show his bosses off. Of course, once that is done - what to do with Ambrose? Grim as it sounds, the film is amusing. But it had few of the typical bits that Skelton movies had, especially those he did with Buster Keaton. The one exception is the conclusion which I would like to think that Keaton had something to do with, for it's logic, and it's sweet symmetry.

SO SPOILER COMING UP (sorry!):

Ambrose does show up his bosses. His careful study of the stone enabled him to know exactly where the right spot to hit it was. So there are now two halves of the stone, perfectly cut, each about the size of a trimmed half of a fat pear. But Louis and his gang (who have been chasing Ambrose and Maggie) are pounding on the door of the room that he used to cut the stone. They have to hide the jewel or these thugs will take it.

Then we see the police arrive and arrest Louis and his thugs, and Ambrose lets them in. He and Maggie are glad to be rescued and explained they protected the stone. How? Well there was no place to hide it in that room, so each of them swallowed half the stone! Really? they are asked. Yes says Ambrose, and then his face shows a growing agony in his intestines, mirrored by a similar one in Maggie's. They are rushed to a hospital and taken into surgery on parallel gurneys. We see them coming out of their anesthetic fog at the same time, and both are presented with a look at their temporary "twin" babies! Sweet little ending that.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Subdued last film comedy starring Red Skelton
vincentlynch-moonoi19 June 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I suspect that once Red Skelton moved into television, MGM got its revenge by filling out his movie contract with the 3 last films that were pretty run-of-the-mill pump them out movies. And this was the last of that bunch. Oh, it's not a bad film, but it's nothing special, either. In it, Skelton plays an orphaned adult who seeks his family, as he works as a diamond cutter. He falls for a con man's (lawyer's) routine who promises to find his family...for a fee. The family he finds is, of course, fake. And deceitful...they want to use Skelton's job to steel an expensive diamond.

The cast here is actually quite good. In addition to Red, who is at his sentimental (not comedy) best here, the cast includes Cara Williams as the fake sister...who ultimately falls in love with him, a fairly young James Whitmore as the detective, Kurt Kasznar as one of the crooks, and Reginald Owen as the owner of the jewelry store. Each does his/her job sufficiently, but no one stands out, either.

If you like sentimental light comedies, this will do fine, but don't expect the uproarious laughs you might have found in some of the other Skelton MGM comedies. It's an okay 70 minutes.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Red Skelton caught up in Adventure
ksf-21 May 2014
"Ambrose C. Park. That's the name they gave me. On account of that' s where they found me. Ambrose Central Park". Red Skelton tells us the premise of the film in another of his madcap capers, in his prime. The film opens with Ambrose in the park, hoping to meet up with the parents who had left him in there all those years ago. He meets up with a shady character who is determined to help him find his long lost parents, for a fee. His new lawyer "friend" Remlick (James Whitmore) quickly puts together a family for Park to meet, and then the adventure begins. Keep an eye out for Reginald Owen, who was in SO many films.. notably as the Admiral in Mary Poppins. It's entertaining, but Skelton plays it pretty serious in this one, for a change. Cara Williams plays his sister Maggie, with Dorothy Stickney as "Mom". Park also gets into scrapes with Maggie's boss, and his own boss at work. This is listed as a comedy, but while the script moves right along, there are many sad moments, and the actual comedy is pretty sparse. His big, happy "family" of small time hoods tries to talk him into doing some un-ethical things at work, and he has some un-expected help leading up to big finale. This was the last time Skelton worked with Director Robert Leonard, and in fact, Leonard only made a couple more films after this one. If you are not familiar with Leonard's stellar list of projects, check out his list of films at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Z._Leonard ; he made some real biggies, and was Oscar-nominated for the Great Ziegfeld and for The Divorcée. The Great Diamond Robbery isn't any Shakespeare piece, but historically, it's one of Skelton's films, and a whole lot easier to watch than a Shakespeare! Written by László Vadnay, who had also written Copacabana (Groucho and Carmen Miranda) and Tales of Manhattan (WC Fields).
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Ambrose Central Park
bkoganbing29 August 2014
In what clearly was a B picture and no frills other than the comic genius of Red Skelton MGM bid farewell to Skelton with The Great Diamond Robbery. I will say that MGM did give him a good supporting cast.

Red is a foundling who goes by the name of Ambrose C. Park, the "C" stands for Central. He was a baby taken in and raised by Reginald Owen and apprenticed in the jewelry trade. But he's Red Skelton and diamond cutter though he be Owen will not trust him in the cutting of a famous diamond in his possession.

But shyster lawyer James Whitmore gets a hold of the naive and unworldly Skelton who's not as bad as Peter Sellers in Being There, but close enough. He gets George Matthews, Dorothy Stickney, and Cara Williams to play his long lost parents and sister. Later on some higher up on the food chain crooks Kurt Kaszner and Harry Bellaver cut themselves in on the jewel caper they've planned which can be accomplished once they've conned Skelton into cutting the valuable diamond.

More pathos than some of Skelton's more outlandish physical comedy which can be found more on television in which he was spending more time is in The Great Diamond Robbery. Next to Skelton, the women in this film are the most memorable with Stickney especially funny as the old moll as the new Mom.

Skelton fans will appreciate this, but it's not one of his better films.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
***
edwagreen30 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
The film was only 75 minutes and stars Red Skelton as an assistant diamond cutter who is never given the opportunity to cut a big diamond.

By accident, Red falls in with a band of crooks led by crooked attorney James Whitmore. Red has been searching for his parents since he was abandoned as a baby and Whitmore comes up with a bogus family for him who plot to take all his money and then when they learn what he does for a profession, to steal the diamond.

Cara Williams plays his "sister" and eventually she and "mother" Dorothy Stickney realize that honesty is the best policy by turning in the rest of the gang.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
If you like Red Skelton, this is the last MGM film the comedian made
jacobs-greenwood19 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This – the last MGM film of Red Skelton – minor comedy was directed by Robert Z. Leonard and written by Martin Rackin and László Vadnay . In addition to the headliner comedian, the cast includes Cara Williams, James Whitmore, Kurt Kasznar and Reginald Owen, among others.

Skelton plays an accomplished diamond cutter (!) that has worked for Bainbridge Gibbons (Owen) for 20 years. Found as an abandoned infant on a bench under an umbrella in the city park, Skelton's character was so named – Ambrose C. Park – and grew up in an orphanage until he came of age and met Gibbons, who took Ambrose under his wing and into his business. Desperate to find his real family, Skelton hires a lawyer, a scam artist named Mr. Remlick (Whitmore), who sets up a phony family of peer scammers – 'father' Duke Fargoh (George Mathews), 'mother' Emily (Dorothy Stickney) and 'sister' Maggie (Williams) – hoping to get Ambrose's $8,000 life's savings.

But then Duke discovers something that Remlick had overlooked: Ambrose's connection to Gibbons, and that Gibbons has a huge $2 million diamond – the Blue Goddess – which he'd like to have split, in order to create a market for its sale. So Duke involves gangster Tony Medeli (Kasznar) and his 'heavy' Herb (Harry Bellaver) as 'Uncles' Tony and Herb in hopes of making an even bigger score.

Since Skelton's character is a naïve 'square', the ruse proceeds, especially when the crooks – after learning that Gibbons doesn't believe Ambrose can make the delicate cut, and hence has been hiring world renown experts that Ambrose is worried will turn the diamond into dust – play the angle that they believe Ambrose can do it, and convince him to try.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Red Skelton comedy
SnoopyStyle13 November 2022
Diamond cutter assistant Ambrose C. Park (Red Skelton) is always looking for his parents who left him as a baby on a park bench. He places an ad on his every birthday. Corrupt lawyer Remlick (James Whitmore) decides to trick him out of his life savings of $8k by bringing him a fake family. Emmily Drummon (Dorothy Stickney) and Duke Fargoh (George Mathews) play his fake parents. Maggie Drummon (Cara Williams) plays his fake sister. Remlick gets overshadowed by other con men who are looking to steal a big diamond.

This seems to have good potential for comedy. It has Red Skelton and a slightly left-of-center premise. It's a little quirky, but not really funny. Park is a hopeful idiot and a clueless romantic. He's an amiable enough character. I like the guy. The material could be funny, but it's a fine light comedy crime thriller.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
OK film
jfarms19567 May 2013
This Film is for those who are 10 and older. I was hoping for a funnier Red Skelton film. Not to say that the film is not comical, I was just a little disappointed that it wasn't funnier. I really like Red Skelton and grew up watching his TV show. My dad turned it on when it was on TV and we watched it together. Red Skelton has a wonderful warm sense of humor that loving hearts will find enjoyable. His humor is never mean. The film is short and gets right to the point, which I like. The Great Diamond Robbery substitutes humor for suspense. Grab your popcorn bowls and enjoy the film. Because of its length, you will have the time for another film. I give this film four thumbs up.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Well worth your time.
planktonrules3 August 2016
It's weird, but the full summary on this site for this film tells you exactly how the movie ends! Try NOT to read the summary!!!

Back in 1919, Ambrose Park (Red Skelton) was left on a bench in Central Park and his parents never returned--so he was raised in an orphanage. He is grown but has a compulsive need to find his parents and goes to the bench regularly...hoping they'll return. Some crooks learn about this and Ambrose's job as an assistant diamond cutter and they plan on exploiting it. They pose as his long-lost family and announce themselves to Ambrose. What he doesn't realize is that this is all a scheme to rob his boss of a super-valuable diamond and they'll then force Ambrose to cut it for them. Can Ambrose realize the ruse before it's too late?

While this is Skelton's last film for MGM (a studio he'd been with since 1940), this does not mean it's a bad one. On the contrary, too often Skelton was saddled with films that were jam-packed with song and dance numbers--something that was NOT his forte. He was a funny man...and here in "The Great Diamond Robbery" he's allowed to be funny...and is well supported with a funny supporting cast as his fake family. Well worth seeing and among Skelton's better films.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed