Iron Man (1951) User Reviews

He fought like an animal and the public hated him.

[mikefive · 7/10 · 9 April 2005]

This film is a remake of Iron Man of 1931 with Lew Ayres and Jean Harlow, also made in 1937 as Some Blondes are Dangerous, but here Evelyn Keyes, the blonde is not the central character. Jeff Chandler, Rock Hudson and James Arness are workers in a mine and also boxers. Chandler wins his fights when he hates and gets furious, he becomes an animal and also the public does not like him. Rock Hudson is the nice guy and Evelyn Keyes is Chandler's girlfriend and Stephen McNally his brother and also agent. The fight scenes do not look very real, specially when Chandler gets punched on the face, it does not seem to affect him, it is almost like he does not defend himself, he only cares about hitting. I think that in a real fight he would be knocked out in a couple of minutes fighting this way. The film is interesting, specially because of the presence of Hudson and Arness at the beginning of their careers.

Coke and Speed - the names of fighters, not drugs

[blanche-2 · 6/10 · 18 September 2021]

An interesting artifact from 1951, "Iron Man" stars Jeff Chandler, Evelyn Keyes, Stephen McNally, Jim Backus, and Rock Hudson.

I will start out by saying I was incredibly distracted by Rock Hudson's high, nasal speaking voice. It's not unusual as a person ages for their voice to drop, especially if they smoked. I don't know if Hudson smoked, but I do know he had surgery to lower his voice.

The surgeon removes a layer of cartilege from the vocal cords. This makes the cords less taut and lowers the pitch. The consequence of that was that he was unable to sing. After hearing him in this movie, it was a small price to pay.

The story concerns a man, Coke Mason (Chandler), a coal miner, whose brother (McNally) wants him to become a professional boxer. His girlfriend (Keyes) does as well, because of the money.

Coke's problem is that when he is hurt in a fight, and the audience boos him, he goes into a rage and becomes a killing machine, usually having to be dragged off of his opponent. He's what is known as a dirty fighter, and the fight audiences hate him.

Originally he wants to quit; then he decides against it and wants to go for the title. By the time he gets to the title, his opponent is Speed (Hudson), a fellow coal miner worker who used to work in Coke's corner during fights.

Chandler and Hudson are unbelievably young in this film. The fight sequences aren't very good, probably because Chandler and Hudson were being marketed as hunks, and the film was intended to appeal to women.

The acting was okay; Rock frankly had a way to go in the acting department.

One of the reviews mentioned Jeff Chandler was a cross-dresser. Jane Russell claims Esther made it up to sell more books, as Williams confided in her often about her affair with Chandler and somehow never managed to mention his cross-dressing. As another actress pointed out, what the heck would he have worn? He was huge. And nobody else saw it?

Boxers and Beefcake

[dinky-4 · 6/10 · 12 October 2000]

A well-cast Jeff Chandler, in his physical prime at about age 32, plays a Pennsylvania miner named "Coke" Mason who reluctantly becomes a boxer in order to earn some extra money. (He wants to use this money to marry girlfriend Evelyn Keyes and open up a radio store.) "Coke" is a mild-mannered fellow who proves to be an indifferent fighter until he's goaded into anger. Then, with an almost audible "click," he turns on his opponent in a murderous rage and attacks him without mercy. This streak of brutality quickly earns him the enmity of the crowd even as it causes his rapid rise in the standings. Meanwhile his friend and fellow boxer "Speed" O'Keefe (Rock Hudson) has the boyish good looks and clean-cut manner which make him a crowd favorite. Inevitably the two meet in the ring to decide the world heavyweight championship.

These ingredients could easily be combined into a serviceable B-movie but there's a problem here: the character played by Evelyn Keyes. The script can't decide whether she's the faithful girlfriend who's appalled by the violence of the boxing ring or instead the greedy golddigger who sees her boyfriend as a means to a life of wealth and comfort. This confusion about her character proceeds to muddle the script's conception of other characters. Stephen McNally as Chandler's ambitious brother also has the makings of a villain as does Joyce Holden as the "other woman." However, since Keyes might (or might not) be the story's real villain, these two characters are often left in a state of limbo -- not quite good, not quite bad. An air of indecision thus lingers over many parts of the movie and keeps it from having the desired impact.

The movie's fight scenes lack the gritty reality of those in, say, "Raging Bull," but this movie almost seems slanted at a female audience so instead of blood and bruises we get attractive "beefcake" shots of Chandler's and Hudson's bare torsos, gleaming with sweat and shaved of hair. (Knowing what we do now of these two actors' private lives, it's easy to imagine how much they enjoyed filming these "beefcake" scenes -- not to mention getting buck naked for the showers that followed!) Fans of "beefcake" get a bonus in also seeing James Arness stripped to the waist for an early fight scene with Chandler.

Though it's hard to imagine Rock Hudson as the heavyweight champion of the world, he has an eager, likable quality that hasn't yet been hardened by the movie-star status soon to settle around him.

This "Iron Man" is a re-make of a 1931 "Iron Man" starring Jean Harlow. Notes indicate that the Jean Harlow version was also re-made in 1937 under the title "Some Blondes Are Dangerous" but information on this movie seems to be missing from the files.

Finally, you can tell how old this movie is by one simple fact: virtually all the boxers in it are white!

Interesting Story, Dissapointing fight sequences

[sutcal · 6/10 · 2 January 2000]

Jeff Chandler plays Coke Mason a coal miner who has a "killer like fighting instinct when provoked). His brother George (Stephen McNally) recognises this and convinces Coke that fighting will earn him more than enough money to open up the radio shop he dreams of owning with his Gal Rose (Evelyn Keyes).

Thats about all of the plot I will give away. The movie also starred a young Rock Hudson who plays the "nice guy" Tommy Speed O'Keefe ( I can understand how Rock was a ladies favourite).

The storyline did enough to keep me interested however the fight scenes which really are crucial to the character development of Coke Mason were atrocious. Yes the movie is 49 years old now, but Chandler's attempt at demonstrating ring skills were laughable. He looks more like the HunchBack of Notre Dame rather than a deranged "maniac fighter". His opponents would have more likely buckled over in laughter at seeing his stance.

To ensure that Jeff Chandler came over as a nice guy by movies end and ensure a happy ending for all, Coke goes from dirty to clean by movies end and wins the respect of all. It would have been a better plot for Coke to self destruct and chronicle how the win at all costs attitude can destroy you. I assume however that at the time Chandler wanted to remain a fan favourite and good guys did that.

I gave the movie a 6/10.

Do you think "Coke" is ready for "Speed"?

[sol-kay · 7/10 · 23 August 2010]

***SPOILERS*** Working in the Coaltown Pennsylvania coal mines for a living Coke Mason, Jeff Chandler, looks forward to opening up his own business repairing and selling radios. It's later that Coke is forced into a boxing match with the far bigger Alax Mallick, James Arness, because Coke won a bet with him in who can mine more coal in a one hour period. Coke after taking it on the chine for the entire first round suddenly put the big guy away with a vicious left right combination.

It seemed that the meek and pacifistic Coke had a mean streak under his harmless facade. That streak surfaced when Coke got pushed around which Mallick, in him being knocked unconscious, was unfortunate enough to find out. This wild and uncontrollable animal inside Coke had his older brother and coal mine foreman George, Steven McNally, as well as his fiancée Rose Warren, Evelyn Keys, come to see him as their meal ticket to get out of Coaltown and then start a new and much better life. The only problem with all this is that Coke is not exactly normal when he's fighting someone. With his cave man and animal like style of fighting he may very well end up killing someone in the boxing ring! Or even worse, for Coke, with his ability to take enormous amounts of punishment end up getting killed himself!

The movie "Iron Man" has an at first reluctant Coke being matched up with a number of pushovers that he easily makes mincemeat out of until he's matched against Joe Savella, Steve Martin, for the Heavyweight Championship of the World. Taking an unbelievable beating from the much more skillful Savella Coke ends up losing when his brother and manager, not being able to see Coke take any more punishment, throws in the towel thus ending the fight.

Coke feeling both hurt and humiliated over his loss to Savella now becomes obsessed in having a rematch and evening the score with him. What Coke is totally unaware of is that things are being set up by not only his brother George and boxing promoter Max Watkins, Jim Backus, but Rose as well for Savella to throw his match with him thus making Coke the new Heavyweight Champion of the World. With Coke being the most hated and despised fighter in professional boxing due to his dirty like tactics, like rabbit punching and hitting his opponents when their still down, is a gold mine for promoters in getting the boxing arenas packed solid.

Resentful in him being suspected in having his Heavyweight Championship Crown won undeserved, by Savella throwing the fight with him, Coke then instead of retiring from boxing, which he promised Rose he'll do, goes on a "Bum of the Month" campaign taking on all comers and, to the great disappointment of the boxing crowd and sports writers, knocking them out cold.

It's when Coke is matched against his good friend and former sparing partner Tommy "Speed" O'Keefe, Rock Hudson, that a sudden change comes over him. Knowing that in his wild and unethical, as well as dirty, tactics in the ring he may well end up killing or permanently injuring Tommy. Trying for the first time in his professional boxing career to fight a good hard as well as clean fight Coke not only ends up getting a cheering ovation from the crowd, who at first hated his guts, but the love and respect of Tommy who used to looked up to Coke as a big brother as well as Rose who had earlier dumped him!

Fine boxing action sequences done in newsreel, not Hollywood, style photography makes "Iron Man" one cut, or punch, above what your used to seeing in boxing films on the silver screen. Even though Jeff Chandler, who's in real life a strapping six foot four inch 200 pounds, was a bit awkward in his boxing scenes, he sometimes looked like he was standing and walking on stilts, he was still very believable in them.

***SPOILERS*** The by far the best thing in the movie wasn't Jeff Chandler's, or Coke Mason's, fight scenes but his genuine humanity which was buried under the rage and fury that overtook him whenever he stepped into a boxing ring. It was those very noble and human feelings towards his opponent Tommy "Speed" O'Keefe that in the end brought the very best out of him. And despite him losing they Made Coke a true champion in the eyes of both his very few friends and many enemies that he, at that time, had in the world.

Decent....but not much more.

[planktonrules · 6/10 · 15 February 2019]

The film begins with a crowded auditorium booing the champ, Coke Mason (Jeff Chandler), as he enters the ring for a title defense. His wife who is there in the audience has a flashback and you see Coke going from coal miner (a rather obvious name for a coal miner, I know) to champion. He had no interest in boxing...mostly because when Coke loses his temper he only wants to kill his opponent...an urge Coke has kept in check all his life. But his wife and brother push and push him until ultimately he enters the ring....and is reviled by most everyone due to his being a dirty fighter. What's next? See the film.

This is a mediocre film in a genre filled with excellent boxing movies. Much of what happens is pretty predictable and the character played by Rock Hudson is pretty poorly written and acted...plus Hudson was all wrong to be playing a boxer. Overall, a decent time-passer and not a lot more to it than that.

I Don't Think Coke is Ready For Speed

[bloan2112 · 6/10 · 10 September 2022]

A routine but interesting boxing movie with a pre greying Jeff Chandler aka Coke finally meeting up with his old friend an early Rock Hudson aka Speed in the ring.

Inadvertent comical names for the time.

The action isn't convincing, the actors don't have the look or moves that simulate a good boxer in later movies.

It does have a noir atmosphere that keeps you watching.

Jim Backus also has a role as a newspaper man turned manager.

I like seeing these 40s and 50s movies for the style and catching actors before they made it big.

Was hoping they'd made a sequel with boxers Crack and Meth getting in the ring with Coke.

No such luck.

Mild-manner man become killer in the ring

[ford-greg · 7/10 · 8 November 2012]

This is an entertaining movie, but one that goes for the cheap, easy ending, where Jeff Chandler's character of Coke decides to fight clean and loses to Rock Hudson's Speed. I think it would have been a better to have Coke be so angry about his former friends abandoning him that he approaches the O'Keefe fight with such fury, displaying it in the ring as well, that he ends up either killing or seriously injuring O'Keefe. Only then does he realize what his style of fighting can do. Perhaps, in the end he redeems himself by fighting with more restraint in the next battle, and losing, or maybe, as someone pointed out here earlier, his win at all costs drive makes him an outcast. Let me say, that despite the rather cheesy ending, The Iron Man is a good movie, well acted and worth watching.

Jeff Chandler Grows Up

[boblipton · 7/10 · 4 February 2020]

Jeff Chandler is a coal miner who wants to open a radio store with his girl, Evelyn Keyes. His brother, Stephen McNally, manages him, as much as anyone can. In the ring, Chandler turns into an animal, barely held back from killing his opponents. Sports columnist Jim Backus keeps writing that he should be thrown out of boxing. When Miss Keyes and McNally pay off another boxer to throw the fight, and Chandler finds out, he walks out, determined to become the world champion and earn the respect of the booing crowds.

I haven't seen the 1931 version of this movie, in which Tod Browning directs Lew Ayres in the lead role, but this is as brutal a movie as the Production Code would permit. Carl Guthrie's camerawork makes Chandler look like an animal during the matches. While there's some pop psychology to explain Chandler's savagery, that is the point of this effective movie.

Bob

Lure of the ring

[jgcorrea · 5/10 · 26 November 2019]

A coal miner who dreams of his own radio shop is lured into a boxing ring where he becomes a kind of animal hated by the public. Box is a film genre that remains to this day committed to tradition. It underwent few changes in dramatic elements or peculiarities of plots. Old scripts used to tell the same stories. They hardly become outdated. (Take the Rocky franchise for example) Most often (like here) it's the story of a poor guy who finds self-fulfillment in fighting, in order to be successful. At the same time either old friends break with him or he with them. Finally, a decision must be made as to whether the hero will look back to his former values or allow success within such a brutal business lose him in every respect. Director Joseph Pevney has some interesting titles in his filmography, but Iron Man surely isn't the best one.

Fourth-billed Rock Hudson breaks away from the pack in obscure, worthy fight flick

[bmacv · 8/10 · 8 August 2003]

Can it be merely coincidence, even in the relative innocence of 1951, that the boxers in Iron Man go by the names of Coke and Speed? (The fact that they're played by Jeff Chandler and Rock Hudson, whom viewers today will identify as, respectively, a cross-dresser and a gay man, adds another latter-day dimension to their sweat-lubricated clinches.) In any case, their stimulating monikers do no injustice to the story – a jacked-up, strung-out fight movie that's a worthy entry in that oddly distinguished, brutal genre.

It starts in Coaltown, Pennsylvania, a mining community where the only excitement is wondering when the shafts will cave in. When Chandler takes on a bully and thoroughly thrashes him, his brother (Steve McNally) and girl (Evelyn Keyes) see a glamorous future and fast money for him – and for them. The only catch is that Chandler isn't a born boxer: He's clumsy and gets pummeled. But when he's hurt (and then jeered at), he falls into blind, murderous rages, going after his opponents by fair means or foul. He wins purses and titles but not the hearts of the fans – they don't like dirty fighters, and come only in hopes of seeing him get his comeuppance. But they keep coming, and soon Chandler's poised for the heavyweight title.

The story, ably directed by Joseph Pevney, follows a familiar course: The fallings-out with his brother and his wife, the big-time sportswriter who becomes his manager (Jim Backus), the fixed fight, the fallacious sense of invincibility. And the ending is a little too pat and feel-good. But it's one of Chandler's best roles (he's as good as Kirk Douglas in The Champion, if not so convincing as Robert Ryan in The Set-Up, both of two years earlier). Evelyn Keyes has but two things to do: First egg him on, then beg him to stop, but she's, as always, distinctive. (She gets slugged by him, too.)

Hudson's another case entirely. In the part of the loyal sparring-partner who turns into the challenger, he's confined to playing L'il Abner – a good-natured but dim-witted lout. But in the final grudge-match, he reverts to the sheer, feral physicality of which he was capable but rarely called upon to display – and, in its final scene, he all but steals the movie away from Chandler. He's the breakout star.

Iron Man

[CinemaSerf · 6/10 · 26 November 2023]

Now I did struggle with the idea of Jeff Chandler as a red-misted boxing champion, but here he acquits him self adequately enough. He's coal miner "Coke" who dreams of wedding his girl "Rose" (Evelyn Keyes) and buying a radio store. His rather more venal brother "George" (Stephen McNally) runs a pool hall and discovers that when his sibling gets cross, really cross, his fists can do his talking for him. The ring beckons, and success follows - but at a price. "Coke" is a brute. He fights legal, but dirty - and the crowd gradually learn to loathe him. Finally he has had enough and wants to stop, but discovers that his now wife is embroiled in some match-fixing with "George" and he faces quite a dilemma - one epitomised at the denouement with a bout with the equally unlikely pugilist Rock Hudson ("Speed"). It's another of the stories set in an industrial town where opportunities were scant and where boxing was a route out if you were prepared to take and give a beating. This one tries to introduce the concept of a conscience in the lead character and the photography does give some sort of indication as to the brutality in the ring. It's a solid film that has just about enough action and a message to convey about right (hooks) and wrong.

Killer Instinct

[bkoganbing · 5/10 · 24 August 2015]

In another few years coal miner turned boxer turned actor Charles Bronson would have been perfect to star in this film which was almost autobiographical in his case. Like Jeff Chandler in this film, Bronson was brought up in the Pennsylvania coal mining country and took up boxing before acting as a way out of some dire poverty.

Chandler plays coal miner Coke Mason who only wants to earn enough money to start a business and get married to Evelyn Keyes. But his brother Stephen McNally sees a future in Chandler's fists and wants to manage him.

Chandler has one thing that can't be taught. He has a murderous punch and a killer instinct in the ring. Lots of fighters have that, two of the most prominent were Jack Dempsey and Rocky Graziano. In fact in that aspect this version of Iron Man is close to the Graziano film Somebody Up There Likes Me.

The main weakness in the film is there is no real explanation for why Chandler is such an animal in the ring. Especially since one of the supporting characters is Rock Hudson who is from those same mines and also becomes a boxer, but he uses skill and speed and is a fan favorite. Chandler is as unpopular as one of Vince McMahon's patented wresting villains.

It's a good boxing film, but this version of Iron Man will never rank with a film like Champion where another prize fighter has a killer instinct.

Yeah, no.

[bombersflyup · 2/10 · 16 April 2024]

Iron Man is one of the stupidest film's ever...

You can't win solely by intent. You can be more dedicated, putting in more hours to your craft, but suggesting that someone who can't technically fight can win purely on murderous intent is ridiculous. Along with some of the opponents giving up because he's merely attacking them. It's like if the "Rocky" films were based solely on the fighting, getting punched until they get tired. In the end he's matched up with a friend, therefore not enraged and wins in life by losing, gaining admiration of the crowd. The protagonist's a miserable watch and those around him aren't much better.

Well-acted garbage

[gford-16745 · 1/10 · 24 April 2024]

The story here focuses on Jeff Chandler's "Coke," who is labeled a dirty fighter, even though all he does fight in close, and wails away on his foes, mostly with clean punches. His first victim is a young James Arness, whom Coke starts pounding and puts against the ropes to finish him off. It's a common tactic, but one which earns Coke the enmity of those watching. Later, Arness. Still recovering from his beating, cries about Coke's style like a man who brought a knife to a gun fight.

If anything, his real-life counterpart was probably Jack Dempsey, who bulled his way through opponents on his to winning the heavyweight crown and then defending it. Later, in the mid-50s, Rocky Marchiano used a similar style to pulverize 49 foes in 49 fights.

Somehow, the crowds loved them, but, here, Coke is a villain, while his good friend Speed is the hero because he fights "clean." The two eventually meet in the ring, where Coke somehow redeems himself by fighting "clean" and losing to Speed. At the end, the crowd gives Coke a standing ovation.

Save your time, and skip this holier-than-thou trip through world of pugilism. If you do watching, be prepared to waste about two hours that you'll never get back.

Coke's addiction but not to coal....

[searchanddestroy-1 · 11 January 2024]

That's not the best picture ever made about prize fighting, that's not THE SET UP, THE CHAMPION nor REQUIEM FOR A HEAVYWEIGHT, but better than SOMEONE UP THERE LIKES ME, which was largely overestimated. That said, Universal pictures offered us some other dramas with more or less the same atmosphere: THE SQUARE JUNGLE, starring Tony Curtis and WORLD IN MY CORNER starring this time Audie Murphy. This one presents Jeff Chandler directed by his fellow fetish pal Joseph Pevney, who was for Chandler what Anthony Mann was for Jimmy Stewart, Henry King for Gregory Peck or Richard Thorpe for Robert Taylor. Good gritty and efficient boxing story presented by a convincing producer Aaron Rosenberg and written by a western great specialist Borden Chase himself. What a surprise !!!! Besides this, Jeff Chandler shows one of his most surprising and impressive performances ever. Very ambivalent character for whom the audiences may feel empathy or not.