
| Vincent Price | ... | Himself / ... (89 episodes, 1949-1963) |

| Beverly Garland | ... | Herself - Regular Panelist / ... (51 episodes, 1962-1964) |

| Sebastian Cabot | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (50 episodes, 1962-1969) |

| Mike Stokey | ... | Himself - Host / ... (38 episodes, 1951-1970) |

| Ross Martin | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (38 episodes, 1962-1964) |

| Hans Conried | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (26 episodes, 1951-1970) |

| Richard Long | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (19 episodes, 1962-1964) |
 | Stubby Kaye | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (18 episodes, 1958-1970) |

| Diana Dors | ... | Herself - Regular Panelist / ... (18 episodes, 1962-1963) |

| Ruta Lee | ... | Herself - Regular Panelist / ... (15 episodes, 1962-1963) |
 | Bill Baldwin | ... | Announcer / ... (15 episodes, 1962-1963) |

| Tommy Noonan | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (10 episodes, 1962-1963) |
 | Jan Clayton | ... | Herself - Regular Panelist / ... (10 episodes, 1962) |

| Pat Harrington Jr. | ... | Himself - Host / ... (10 episodes, 1962) |
 | Mickey Manners | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (10 episodes, 1962) |

| Dorothy Hart | ... | Herself - Regular Panelist / ... (6 episodes, 1958-1963) |
 | Robert Clary | ... | Himself - Regular Panelist / ... (6 episodes, 1963-1969) |

| Gisele MacKenzie | ... | Herself / ... (5 episodes, 1962-1969) |

| Jayne Mansfield | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (3 episodes, 1962-1964) |

| Jackie Coogan | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1951-1963) |

| Sammy Davis Jr. | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1952-1962) |

| Jane Russell | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1952-1962) |

| Carol Lynley | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1953-1963) |

| Tom Poston | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1963) |

| Angie Dickinson | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1962-1963) |

| Robert Horton | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1962-1963) |

| Tab Hunter | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1962-1963) |

| Janet Blair | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1962) |

| Gypsy Rose Lee | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1962) |

| Lee Marvin | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1962) |

| Dick Van Dyke | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1962) |
 | Jack Ging | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1963-1964) |

| Frank Gorshin | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1963-1964) |

| Connie Stevens | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1963-1964) |

| Amanda Blake | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1963) |

| James Gregory | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Barbara Hale | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Ty Hardin | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Eartha Kitt | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Roddy McDowall | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Lizabeth Scott | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |
 | Grant Williams | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Karen Valentine | ... | Herself (2 episodes, 1970) |
|
 | Art Fleming | ... | Announcer (unknown episodes) |

| Angela Lansbury | ... | Herself (unknown episodes) |
 | Spring Mitchell | ... | Herself (assistant) (unknown episodes) |

| George O'Brien | ... | Himself (unknown episodes) |
 | Sandra Spence | ... | Herself (assistant) (unknown episodes) |