The Counterfeit Cat (1949) User Reviews

An obvious knock-off of Sylvester and Tweety--but still a lot of fun

[planktonrules · 8/10 · 25 November 2006]

While this is a Tex Avery directed cartoon, it's about the most conventional cartoon for the studio that I can recall having seen. Just a year or two before this Avery MGM cartoon was made, Sylvester and Tweety over at Looney Toons were coming into their own as a team. This MGM cartoon is an obvious attempt to create a knock-off of the popular series--with a few cute twists. This film is about a cat pretending to be a dog so it can sneak into a home and eat the canary (called, of all things, "Tweety Bird"). It seems that Butch the dog believes this cat in disguise is his friend and most of the cartoon the cat tries to distract the dog so it can eat the personality-deprived bird (it's not much like Tweety--it never tries to kill the cat even once). To distract the dog, the cat keeps giving him a seemingly endless supply of bones. This leads to a very funny conclusion to the film when the dog finally catches on to the ruse. I don't want to spoil it, but it is a funny and interesting twist.

One of Tex Avery's most sight-gag oriented cartoons

[llltdesq · 8/10 · 21 December 2000]

This cartoon is almost entirely sight-gags and is about a cat willing to go to great lengths to have a bird join him-as dinner! Only there's one minor inconvenience-a rather large, if somewhat dim, dog watching out for the bird's welfare. Delightfully funny and the ending is just perfect. Personally, I think the cat would have been better off ordering a pizza! Most recommended.

The cat, the dog and the canary

[TheLittleSongbird · 8/10 · 5 November 2017]

Love animation, it was a big part of my life as a child, particularly Disney, Looney Tunes and Tom and Jerry, and still love it whether it's film, television or cartoons.

Also have much admiration for Tex Avery, an animation genius whose best cartoons are animated masterpieces and some of the best he ever did. 'The Counterfeit Cat' is not one of his best, not that it does anything wrong as such but more to do with that the many things that are done very well have been done even better and with a little more spark and originality in a lot of his other work. Even when Avery was not quite at the top of his game he put many other animation directors to shame and the cartoons in general much better than many at their worst. Hope that doesn't sound too hyperbolic, unfair or ignorant.

The story is 'The Counterfeit Cat's' weakest element, still very well paced and fun but conceptually it somewhat familiar.

However, much of the animation is very good. Very rich in colour, the backgrounds have meticulously good detail and the character designs are distinctively Avery in style and are fluid in movement. The music, courtesy of Scott Bradley, is lushly and cleverly orchestrated, with lively and energetic rhythms and fits very well indeed, even enhancing the action.

Can't fault Avery, whose style is all over, nor the dynamic voice acting and the very engaging characters, especially Spike. The pacing is very lively and 'The Counterfeit Cat' is incredibly funny throughout. There couldn't have been a more perfect ending.

Overall, very well done. 8/10 Bethany Cox

The Cat Goes 'Bow-Wow'

[boblipton · 7/10 · 21 January 2023]

A hungry cat disguises himself as a dog. He hopes to fool the big bulldog guarding a canary so he can eat it -- the canary, that is. And then it's the usual long series of Tex Avery gags.

It's not that I wish to object to the long series of Avery gags, which I find as funny as ever. Some of the gags are truly unexpected, so I won't even begin to discuss them, but hope that you find them as I did.

The big problem with rating Tex Avery MGM cartoons is that they are all very funny. Do I compare them with other cartoon directors, or do I rank them according to Avery's other cartoons? Alas, I have decided to use a blended rating.

This picture deserves a substantial rating for so well . . .

[pixrox1 · 8/10 · 7 August 2022]

. . . illustrating the fact that Tinsel Town's infamous "Poverty Row" film studios were as likely to wind up in the abhorrent backwaters for their impoverished ideas as for their usually concurrent money woes. THE COUNTERFEIT CAT is brazenly titled thus to taunt Warner Brothers for this attempted theft of their beloved Sylvester Cat. Though Leo's fraudulent feline is anonymous here, the bird he keeps ingesting is blatantly referred to as "T-w-e-e-t-y." IF this was an original idea, surely it would be labeled as The Counterfeit DOG. However, some third-rate dude named Avery was subsidized by Leo--after being fired by Warner for moral turpitude--and given the promise that judges would be bribed to heap coveted gelded statuettes upon Avery's noggin as a "thank you" for ripping off as much of Warner's intellectual property as he could.

solid Tex Avery

[SnoopyStyle · 7/10 · 21 January 2023]

An alley cat tries to steal a caged canary in a home, but Spike the dog is blocking the way. The cat tries to disguise himself as a dog by stealing the hair off Spike's neighbor dog friend. With a lots of bones and a ridiculous disguise, he works hard to distract Spike while trying to steal the canary.

This is a Tex Avery MGM cartoon short. I love a couple of his sight gags. They are classics. The canary is obviously copying Tweety. The cat is a little generic, but I always love pairing him with Spike. They are good partners in comedy. This is solid Tex Avery during the golden age of animated short.