IMDb > The Kissing Bandit (1948) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Kissing Bandit More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Page 1 of 2:[1] [2] [Next]
Index 12 reviews in total 

15 out of 18 people found the following review useful:

Musical Mess With a Few Highlights

4/10
Author: sobaok (sobaok@msn.com) from Forestville, Ca
27 November 2001

Perhaps the director was trying for another PIRATE (Good Garland and Kelly musical) -- but this lame musical epoch falls flat. Sinatra and Kathryn Graysons voices do not blend well -- and their chemistry together lacks spark. The premise of Sinatra as a sweet guy who tries to impersonate his late "bandito" father is okay, but he seems awkward in the role. What's amazing and wonderful here, is how Sinatra can take a rather insipid song and make it seem special -- his phrasing and eloquence as a singer make you want to hear it again. When Grayson sings the same songs it's hard to believe she's not singing something entirely different and not nearly as interesting. She has her big moment with "Love Is Where You Find It" which suits her perfectly and shows off her abilities. The photography is lucious and both stars look appealing as do the costumes and sets. Co-stars Mildred Natwick and J. Carroll Nash put lots of energy into making the impossible work. Aside from Sinatra's singing there is a strange menage-a-tois dance with Ricardo Montalban, Cyd Charisse and Ann Miller. It's fascinating and weird. Montalban and Charisse were a wonderful dancing team and this number is a real oddity.

Was the above review useful to you?

12 out of 14 people found the following review useful:

Sinatra finally gets Grayson

4/10
Author: bkoganbing from Buffalo, New York
23 October 2005

The Kissing Bandit was the third and final film that Frank Sinatra and Kathryn Grayson co-starred at MGM with. The first two were Anchors Aweigh and It Happened in Brooklyn. And in both Sinatra wooed and lost Grayson. I guess the third time's the charm.

For romance maybe, but definitely not for screen image. Sinatra in his forty's films once again plays the nice little schnook only this time in toreador pants. Poaching on Tyrone Power's territory laid out in The Mark of Zorro, Sinatra plays the son of a man who was a hotel owner by day and The Kissing Bandit by night. He's gone and left California for an education and has come back ready to take Dad's place, but in the hotel business only. And where does he learn the hotel business, Boston.

Of course some of Dad's former gang members, grown a little old and paunchy led by J. Carrol Naish, want him to lead the gang again. But Frank's just not cut out for the outlaw life. But he does make a good impression on the Governor's daughter, Kathryn Grayson.

Somebody must have had it in for Sinatra at MGM to cast him in this after the bad reviews he got in Miracle of the Bells. Frank's in a part that was more suitable for Red Skelton. But since this was a musical, I guess the brain trust at MGM figured Kathryn Grayson had to have a singing co-star.

In fact the best number in the film are for her, Love Is Where You Find It. Also Ricardo Montalban, Ann Miller, and Cyd Charisse do a dance specialty that is nice. Frank's songs are nice, but nothing spectacular.

In later years, Sinatra would wince at the mention of The Kissing Bandit and with good reason.

Was the above review useful to you?

5 out of 7 people found the following review useful:

Perhaps Sinatra's worst film--and that includes some stiff competition...

2/10
Author: moonspinner55 from las vegas, nv
12 May 2008

A klutzy young man returns West after being schooled in the hotel business via Boston; he quickly learns his friends in Spanish-colonized Old California expect him to fill his deceased father's shoes instead--that of a romantic thief known for kissing his female victims after robbing them. Colorful but silly M-G-M production has a great deal of talent before and behind the camera, but it never takes off. This might have been fun, second-string material for Abbott & Costello, but Frank Sinatra looks lost and embarrassed in the lead. Combination of raucous comedy and musical interludes are hindered by the poor staging (Sinatra is photographed singing at one point in a mirror, but one doesn't concentrate on his performance so much as noticing how odd the star appears reflected in this way!). Kathryn Grayson is the Governor's daughter who falls for Frank, and her high soprano trilling turns her singing scenes into self-parody. Aside from Robert Surtees' cinematography and the decent art direction, this "Bandit" remains kissless. * from ****

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Perfectly enjoyable. Certainly not any worse than any number of other MGM musicals no one remembers

7/10
Author: zetes from Saint Paul, MN
21 February 2010

MGM musical starring Frank Sinatra and Kathryn Grayson. Sinatra plays the son of a businessman who had a secret identity as the Kissing Bandit in California. When his father dies, Sinatra moves from Boston to California to take over the business - and the Kissing Bandit identity. The problem? He's kind of a wuss. During his first raid, he's too afraid to kiss Kathryn Grayson, the daughter of the governor, which causes her to seethe with jealousy. The Kissing Bandit has an awfully low IMDb rating at 4.7, but I didn't think it was that bad. It's certainly no worse than a good chunk of MGM musicals made around the same time. Sure, we could wish it were better, but it's cute enough, funny enough and it has some pretty good songs. Grayson is absolutely adorable in it. The film also includes Cyd Charisse, in what might be her lousiest dance sequence ever (obviously the choreographer's fault) with a whip to charm Sinatra, and Ann Miller and Ricardo Montelbahn (along with another uncredited dancer) share a fine dance as "fiesta specialty dancers".

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Aw, stop it. This was cute!

7/10
Author: silvrdal from OKC
5 December 2009

Okay, so it's not West Side Story, but The Kissing Bandit is darned cute. There were so many silly musicals throughout motion-picture history, I'm surprised that this one is getting such a bad rap.

The 1940's, regardless of how thinly the stories were laid-on, was the most beautiful decade in history for films. The remarkable lighting, set, and costume design of the '40's can make just about every movie enjoyable. Sinatra and Grayson are delightful; any scene in which Kathryn appears is worth watching just because she was so adorable and lovely. Mildred Natwick's role isn't very vivid, but she's a wonderful actress no matter how small the part.

If you don't care for the silliness of the "filler", just fast-forward to any scene with singing, dancing, or an actress -- Heck three of the most beautiful and talented women in film are all in the same movie. Just enjoy the pretty colors and all will be well... sleep... sleeeep...

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Odd musical

2/10
Author: ryancm from United States
8 July 2008

This must be one of MGM's and FRANK SINATRAS worst films. An oddball musical comedy that fails in almost every aspect. Silly plot has SINATRA trying to carry on his fathers reputation as a KISSING BANDIT. He's no bandit and doesn't kiss!! He does play the "nerdy" character as well as could be expected given the dialog he has to speak. The scene stealer's are J. CARROLL NASH and MILDRED NATWICK. Too bad they didn't have more scenes together. I've given the film two stars because the sets and costumes are superior and one of the songs sung by KATHTREN GRAYSON "Love is Where You Find It", is sensational. Could have had a repirse of that one. Also, a comic type dance number by RIDCARDO MANTALBAN, CYD CHARISSE and ANN MILLER if fun. So for those reasons and those reasons only, it is watchable. KISSING BANDIT is part of the Frank Sinatra early years collection.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Not as bad as I expected....

6/10
Author: planktonrules from Bradenton, Florida
26 August 2012

The IMDb score for this film is under 5--indicating it's a bad film. While I agree it is very slight and has many problems, the film isn't bad and is a decent time-passer.

Frank Sinatra is completely wrong for the part, though his singing was great--better than his co-star Kathryn Grayson. He plays a Bostonian who has moved to Mexican California (before it became a part of the US). His thick New Jersey accent sounds completely unlike a Bostonian and midway through the film he is impersonating a man from Spain!! As I said, he's completely wrong for the film.

Sinatra moves to California to assume control of his father's inn. However, he doesn't realize that inn-keeping was NOT his father's real job--he was the infamous 'Kissing Bandit'. When the father's old henchman (J. Carrol Naish) informs him he MUST assume control of the old gang and take up the tradition of kissing fair ladies who he robs, Sinatra is afraid--he doesn't think he is up to the task! When he's on his first robbery, he meets a gorgeous lady (Grayson) and ISN'T up to the task--and cannot make himself kiss her. It isn't that he's not attracted--it just seems wrong to kiss a stranger! As for her, she's intrigued...and a bit disappointed he didn't kiss her! The story gets a lot weirder--especially when later Sinatra and Naish pose as emissaries from Spain--and Grayson's father (the Governor) wines and dines them! What's next? Tune in and see.

As for the plot, it's really silly--completely silly, actually. And, in this era of political correctness, it's also likely to offend some of the more feminist bent. But it is fun! What isn't fun, however, is the singing. As I said above, Sinatra is great--with a gorgeous voice as you'd expect. As for Grayson, she has a quality voice but it's also VERY operatic--and hard on the ears. Also, most of the songs are completely forgettable. An odd exception is "Love is Where You Find it". I say odd, because only about a week ago, I heard this EXACT song in the movie "A Date for Judy" in which Jane Powell sang the same tune. While IMDb doesn't indicate it, they sounded EXACTLY the same to me--like one was perhaps not really singing the tune but using a recording of the other woman (though which is which, I have no idea). Overall, not a bad little film but a bit silly and the singing was a definite low-point.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Post-war curiosity

Author: ilprofessore-1 from United States
28 August 2009

A strange post-World War II Technicolor curiosity from the Joe Pasternak musical unit at MGM, which had neither the budget nor the taste of the Arthur Freed unit on the same lot. Set in Mexican California as imagined by the Culver City art department, the bandit Chico is played broadly by the dialectician J. Carrol Naish (Irish) with a fake bulbous nose worthy of W.C. Fields; Don Jose by the Moscow-Art-Theater actor Mikhail Rasumny; and Ricardo by Hoboken-born Italian-American Frank Sinatra in his skinny bobby socker's heart-throb days. Along the way you'll see Ann Miller, Ricardo Montalban and Cyd Charrise dancing and not acting to choreography by soon to be director Stanley Donen. Future cowboy star Ben Johnson did some of the stunts. Cinematography by Robert Surtees is replete with soft- focus close-ups of Kathryn Grayson who often looks as if she was photographed through Vaseline. The film was directed by the Hungarian Laslo Benedek, best remembered today for THE WILD ONE (1963) with Brando. Sad to note, the real Mexicans in the cast were delegated to minor roles.

Was the above review useful to you?

The film would have been stronger had they paired Frank with someone whose singing style wasn't as vastly different.

Author: Jeffrey Roegner from United States
11 April 2013

The Kissing Bandit was an attempt by MGM to build up Frank Sinatra as a leading man. This is a lively, bright, and goofy comedy musical. Sinatra plays Ricardo, a California born, Boston-bred young man who returns to California to take over the family business, not knowing that his father was the infamous Kissing Bandit. So named because he kissed all the women after he was done with his thievery. Ricardo is the last possible candidate to take up his father's mask. He is a proper and uncoordinated, and in his funny entrance he literally crashes through the inn that his father owned, having fallen off of his horse. J. Carroll Naish plays the comic relief on the male side as Chico, who was Ricardo's father's right hand man. Frank Sinatra is fine, but stiff at times in his role.

Sinatra's leading lady is operatic coloratura singer Kathryn Grayson, and this is a strange pairing. When they are doing songs by themselves, both actors shine, but their lone duet in the film (and thank goodness there is only one!) just doesn't work. Sinatra's smooth, jazz crooning is an odd, almost jarring pairing with Grayson's operatic arias. The film would have been stronger had they paired Frank with someone whose singing style wasn't as vastly different. The songs in the film are all good and memorable, including the Grayson solo "Tomorrow Means Romance", the Sinatra solo "Siesta", and my favorite song in the film "What's Wrong With Me?", which both Grayson and Sinatra sing. The songs were written by Nacio Herb Brown and Earl K. Brent. Brown had been paired frequently with Arthur Freed in the '20's and '30's and their songs were later used as the basis for possibly the best known movie musical of all time, Singin' in the Rain. "What's Wrong With Me", in fact, was used in the stage version of Singin'.

In addition to Naish, the film has a fine supporting cast of character actors, including Mildred Natwick as Grayson's man hungry aunt, and Clinton Sundberg as the bumbling Colonel Gomez, who keeps getting demoted. The plot line is thin and pure silliness, and Sinatra and Grayson have a flimsy chemistry, but it is held up by several strong musical performances and two cool dance sequences, one that includes Ricardo Montalban, Cyd Charisse, and Ann Miller. The comedy is not lacking though, and I had a smile on my face throughout. Overall, The Kissing Bandit, provides a fun time-filler for a late night or rainy day.

Was the above review useful to you?

Impressive operatic-like farce, short on comedy

7/10
Author: william walker (weezeralfalfa@yahoo.com) from United States
11 March 2012

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

If, Hope, Skelton, Crosby or even Kelly had taken the place of Sinatra, this much maligned film might be considered an entertaining, if still flawed, lavish romantic musical farce. But, someone with a good voice and style for romantic ballads was needed for the lead role of Ricardo, and Sinatra was the most available choice for MGM at the time.He didn't want to do it, and Kathryn Grayson didn't want her lead role either. In fact, both later said this was their least favorite film role. But, it doesn't really show that much. Yes, Sinatra often looks uncomfortable in his role, but any man would. The main problem is the often trite dialogue that makes the players seem like unbelievable idiots,logical holes in the script, and the characterization of Ricardo, that makes him more suitable for Hope or Skelton to play. If you have seen the Minnelli-directed musical "The Pirate", released around the same time, or the previous non-musical Hope-Mayo-starring "The Princess and the Pirate" farce, you will no doubt see significant similarities in plot and style. However, both these films are rated much higher at IMDb.

The story begins with the death of Ricardo's father: an inn keeper and notorious bandit chief in the Mexican province of Upper California.He was especially noted for kissing the female passengers of the stages he held up, often to their liking.Ricardo(Sinatra),who has been cloistered away in Boston for most of his life(why?), arrives by horse, crashing headfirst through the inn door when his horse stops too suddenly. He learns from innkeeper Chico(J. Carrol Naish) that his father was a famous bandit chief and that he is expected to take his place. No way, Jose, says he. But, he makes a brave attempt at robbing a stage, in which the governor's daughter, Teresa(Kathryn Grayson) is riding. The stage horses bolt, with only Teresa and Ricardo aboard. They get acquainted, and Teresa is disappointed because he refuses to kiss her. Later, at her mansion, she sings "What's Wrong with Me", when told Ricardo kisses all the women. Ricardo,at his inn, sings a version appropriate for him. He then rides to her mansion, and serenades her with "If I Steal a Kiss". But bullets then fly,so he has to leave. Back at his inn, the arrogant Count Belmonte and sleepy General Torro, from Spain, arrive to spend the night, before traveling to collect taxes from the Governor. Chico, Ricardo's new father figure, is caught stealing from their treasure chest, and they fight.The Count and General are tied up, Ricardo and Chico put on their clothes and take their letter of introduction to the Governor. Teresa recognizes them as imposters, but keeps quit. Meanwhile, middle-aged Isabella is warming up to Chico.Teresa sings a version of "If You Steal a Kiss", as a reply to Ricardo's previous serenade. Teresa gets jealous when Ricardo tells her he has kissed many women, but not her, because she is too beautiful.Later, she sings "There is Nothing Wrong with Me", after Ricardo suggests they elope. Ricardo then sings "I Offer You the Moon" and Teresa sometimes chimes in with a reply, as they confirm their love for each other. Later, Teresa sings "Love is Where You Find It" to express her joy. But, the real Count and General then show up, and have Ricardo and Chico thrown in jail. They escape via a halfwit jail keeper, and Ricardo wrestles with the Count, beating him, after he sees him trying to seduce Teresa. At Isabella's suggestion, Chico is appointed the new tax collector. Ricardo tells Teresa he no longer wants to be a bandit, thus she will not be entralled by him. She replies 'no problem' and serenades him with a reprise of "If You Steal a Kiss". He tells her he never was a bandit, never kissed a woman, and inherited none of his father's charisma. She kisses him and faints. He remarks "Or did I".

There are two spectacular specialized dances. At the fiesta, Ann Miller and Cid Charisse compete for Ricardo Montalban in an adaptation of some kind of traditional Mexican dance, I assume.I'm no expert on such. Earlier, Sono Osato(not Cid Charisse, as one reviewer claims)included a spectacular bull whip cracking ballet in her unsuccessful attempted seduction of Ricardo(to divert his attention from the politically dangerous Teresa). Rather reminds me of Astaire's firecracker dance in "Holiday Inn", the whip snapping sounding like firecrackers. Sono was trained in ballet, mostly in Europe, and mostly performed on stage. Most notably, she developed the character 'Miss Turnstiles'in the Broadway musical "On the Town". Vera-Ellen would later take this part in the film version.

I recommend that you give this film a chance, despite Sinatra's and Grayson's relative lack of comedic skills in their roles. Kathryn, at this age, was always a delight to look at, with large expressive eyes. There are a number of decent romantic ballads, although none made the hit parade. Naish's talent as a supporting actor helps make the film more palatable. He would return for a similar comedic role in "The Toast of New Orleans", starring Mario Lanza and Kathryn Grayson. Despite costarring with Sinatra in 3 musicals,Grayson reportedly did not find him romantically attractive.

Was the above review useful to you?


Page 1 of 2:[1] [2] [Next]

Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings External reviews
Plot keywords Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history