The Amazing Mrs. Holliday (1943) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Touching comedy/drama of mistaken identity and lots of surprises.
mark.waltz8 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
When missionary Deanna Durbin arrives in San Francisco with eight young orphans after the ship she was on was torpedoed by the Japanese, she is mistakenly identified as the widow of a ship's commander by his gold-digging family. She confesses the truth to the commander's grandson (Edmund O'Brien) and they slowly develop a friendship that turns into romance. We learn from a well placed flashback of how Durbin ended up on the commander's (Harry Davenport) ship and why the elder members of his family (Grant Mitchell, Elisabeth Risdon and Freida Inescort) believed she had married their elder brother. Durbin decides the facade is necessary to provide the children with a home, and everything is going right until a surprise during a party honoring the late commander occurs.

This is one of Durbin's most tender movies, and all of the children (including one simply billed as "The Chinese baby") are adorable. Barry Fitzgerald stands out as Durbin's confidante, one of the ship's crew members, who helped smuggle Durbin and company aboard the ship. In his brief role, Davenport (Grandpa in "Meet Me in St. Louis") is also great, and Gus Schilling, one of the funniest unknown character actors in films, shines in a brief role as a stranger whom Durbin and O'Brien encounter at Grand Central Station. Durbin briefly sings, but this is not a musical. The film is also important as a view of how important it was for Americans not in combat during World War II to be involved in more ways than just buying war bonds or working the swing shift.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Not much here. A pleasant enough time waster
MikeF-66 March 2003
Several sources report that Jean Renoir, who shot some scenes and was then replaced as director, began this film. If he had completed it, it would have come between Swamp Water and This Land Is Mine. All my efforts to find out more about Renoir's contribution have been fruitless. I even tracked down Renoir's autobiography only to find that he doesn't mention it - not even in passing. Anyhow, Deanna Durbin is the daughter of a China missionary who rescues 8 orphan children (7 of them white) and brings them to the U.S. where they are about to be taken by the '40s version of Child Protective Services. So, she pretends to be the new, young bride of a shipping magnet who she believes was killed in a ship bombing. Romantic comedy complications ensue. I would recommend it mainly for Durbin fans, but also for those who would like to speculate on what it would have been if Jean Renoir has seen it through to completion.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A gentle story of orphans uprooted by war-torn China
lora641 April 2001
This is a heartwarming story that begins with the upheavals of war in China and how young lives find a new life in America. The lovely Deanna Durbin is protector of eight orphans and such is her dedication that she falls in with sailor Barry Fitzgerald's little scheme of pretending to be the widow of the elderly Commodore Holliday, with the resultant confusion, hilarious moments and bittersweet outcomes. Ms Durbin sings some fine old favorites and I particularly liked "Mighty Like a Rose" which she sings beautifully. It has light romance, comedy, and tender moments and is well recommended as excellent family fare.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Different but oddly uneven romantic comedy-drama...
Doylenf18 November 2001
Sentimental tale of a young schoolteacher in war-torn China who sets out to rescue war orphans and take them to America. As in all of Deanna's movies, the plot thickens when she tells a little white lie that has her posing as the widow of a wealthy sailor. Barry Fitzgerald is in on her little scheme and Edmond O'Brien, as the old Commodore's grandson, is soon infatuated with her. It's a sentimental story and, unfortunately, none of it rings true but somehow Durbin overcomes the inadequacies of a weak script and tosses off her songs with grace and authority, as always.

Nominated for Best Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy picture in 1943.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed