IMDb > That Hamilton Woman (1941) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb
That Hamilton Woman
Quicklinks
Top Links
trailers and videosfull cast and crewtriviaofficial sitesmemorable quotes
Overview
main detailscombined detailsfull cast and crewcompany credits
Awards & Reviews
user reviewsexternal reviewsawardsuser ratingsparents guidemessage board
Plot & Quotes
plot summarysynopsisplot keywordsmemorable quotes
Did You Know?
triviagoofssoundtrack listingcrazy creditsalternate versionsmovie connectionsFAQ
Other Info
box office/businessrelease datesfilming locationstechnical specsliterature listingsNewsDesk
Promotional
taglines trailers and videos posters photo gallery
External Links
showtimesofficial sitesmiscellaneousphotographssound clipsvideo clips

Reviews & Ratings for
That Hamilton Woman More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Page 3 of 5: [Prev][1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [Next]
Index 46 reviews in total 

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

One of Vivien Leigh's finest

8/10
Author: samhill5215 from United States
10 November 2008

Vivien Leigh's career is usually defined by her two most famous films, "Gone With the Wind" and "A Streetcar Named Desire". Although certainly good in the first she is magnificent in the second, with an unparalleled maturity and sensibility that defies all explanation. For me Blanche Dubois IS Vivien Leigh.

Having seen "That Hamilton Woman" for the first time recently, Leigh's portrayal kept me riveted and anxious for her next interpretation of that tragic woman's life despite the fact that I am familiar with her history. Perhaps it is because of that familiarity that I was anxious to see how she would act out the events. Nonetheless I was very impressed and can say that "Hamilton" is now my second favorite Leigh film after "Streetcar".

My only beef is with the naval scenes. They needlessly interfered with the film's flow and had little if anything to do with Lady Hamilton's life other than in the way they affected her love affair with Nelson. They could have easily been removed without penalty. Nelson's death at Trafalgar could have easily been covered in the scene where his lieutenant breaks the news to Emma. There was no need for the naval battle scene. After all this wasn't a movie about Nelson but about Emma Hamilton. All that chest beating and heroic music simply took away from what ends up being a tragic love story.

So watch it for Vivien Leigh and fast forward through the battle scenes.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

Firmly among filmdom's greats.

9/10
Author: catuus from United States
14 March 2008

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

I suppose that revealing an historical fact might be considered a spoiler by people basically ignorant of history. So I'm guilty. So shoot me.

I don't say that old movies are always better than new ones – but old movies are usually better than new. This is especially when they're the same movie, and generically so when the old movie has no clone. The old "Four Feathers" is better than the new. The old "Count of Monte Cristo" is better than any of the new. The old Disney movies are better than the new, especially when they're the originals of "What's-Its-Name" II (or III or XXXI). "That Hamilton Woman" is an old film that makes no secret of its aristocratic blood and as yet nobody has had the cajones to remake it.

THW is a Brit film made during the Last Good War (1941) when the Brits were still going it alone and not doing all that badly. It's a wartime reminder of how the British navy kept that nutter Napoleon at bay for almost a generation – even as they kept that loony Hitler at bay during his (gottzei dank!) briefer career. Although the film isn't centered on the man who put paid to Bonaparte's naval pretensions, Horatio Nelson; however, he is an important character.

The main character is Emma Hart, ne Amy Lyon(s) and latterly Emma, Lady Hamilton. The film opens about the end of Emma's life, while she's in jail in Calais for brawling. She tells her story to a cell mate who is also English. This opens in 1783, just as she arrives at the home of Sir William Hamilton – to whose tender care he has committed her now that he intends to marry a lot of money. Hamilton is ambassador to the King of Naples. Emma and her mother, Mary Cadogan-Lyon (formerly Mary Kidd), move into the Hamilton home, where she learns she's been palmed off. Eventually she gets over it and marries Lord Hamilton (1791). During the 1780s she befriends Queen Maria Carolina and moves virtually to the pinnacle of Neapolitan society after her marriage.

The film, I should add, runs fairly close to history. In 1793 Horatio Nelson calls at Naples as part of a campaign to unite Italy against French aggression. Emma is smitten with him, but he almost immediately dashed off to confront a military emergency. After Nelson won the Battle of the Nile at abu-Kir (1798), he returned to Naples, minus an arm, an eye, and a lot of teeth. Nelson spent well over a year in the Hamilton home. Thence he returned to England with the Hamiltons and Emma's mother, arriving in 1800. Once in London, Nelson lived with the other 3. Nelson's daughter Horatia was born in early 1801. Late that year Nelson purchased Merton Place, a fixer-upper to which the quartet moved. The Emma-Horatio affair increasingly became a public scandal and Nelson's wife made their separation final. In 1803 Hamilton died and Nelson finally took up the sea again. He died in 1805 during his great victory at Trafalgar.

We see Emma's downward spiral begin, but we never see its end nor really learn its cause other than unspecified money problems. Emma had a gambling addiction. She died in Calais of liver failure (1815; not in the film).

The film itself is wonderful theater. Winston Churchill said he had seen it over 100 times. The director was the great Alexander Korda and the idiomatic music was by the brilliant Miklós Rózsa. The 5 principal roles are taken by a quintet of Britain's best. Horatio Nelson is played with enormous sincerity and passion by Lawrence Olivier. Sir Larry, which I'm certain nobody ever calls him to his face, was one of those dramaturgic prodigies of which Britain has produced so many and America so few. This rôle, relatively early in his career, already shows his mastery of the art of acting.

As if being treated to Olivier weren't enough, Emma is played by the gorgeous Vivien Leigh. Leigh was a lively, intelligent, radiant actress – no wonder Olivier fell in love with her whilst they were making "Fire Over England". She made few films after THW, mostly due to persistent bouts with tuberculosis. Although she doesn't exactly resemble Emma, she is not exactly unlike her either. Her performance here is, until tragedy begins to overwhelm Emma, chock-full of joie de vivre.

William Hamilton is played by the venerable screen regular (171 films), Alan Mowbray. His aristocratic yet warm bearing allowed him to play a wide variety of roles; he is marvelously effective here. Mowbray spent his last years (1956-1969) appearing in American TV programs.

Emma's mother is portrayed by the estimable and talented Sara Allgood. Her warm, motherly face brought her many parts as a mother, a landlady, a neighbor, what have you.

The important, somewhat smaller, part of Lady Nelson was taken by the wonderful Gladys Cooper. Her bearing and diction led her to such rôles as Duchesses and other nobility or others of like personality. Her best-known rôle was Mrs. Higgins, Henry Higgins' mother, in Shaw's play Pygmalion and the musical made from it, My Fair Lady. As Nelson's wife, her grief shows subtly and clearly below her forbearance. Many who take similar parts could learn much from watching her here.

This DVD is of Chinese manufacture. There is no British or American copy yet. The subtitles are Chinese but not English, alas -- but the actors speak clearly and precisely. When the playback started, the main titles were unclear and the sound was badly reproduced. I expected the worst until the main film started. This had been digitally improved so that the sound was much better. The images were also clear, although the dark tones were somewhat muted. I'm sure the film will eventually come out with a better print, but this isn't half-bad.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

One of the best films ever

7/10
Author: angel_de_tourvel from surrey, england
22 January 2005

This is a great film and no mistake. Vivien Leigh is just so breathtakingly stunning as the beautiful Emma Hamilton (Lady Hamilton was the most beautiful woman in Europe or even the world at the time so I'm glad they cast the right person!!) Laurence Olivier was also fine as Nelson, though occasionally hamming up some parts with Vivien (understandably so, since Vivien seduces him on screen and off) But you can feel the chemistry a mile off and thats what matters. Another thing, and this is why its Churchill's favourite: IT's sOOOO pro ENGLAND!!! Its fantastic. They just all ooze in the greatness of their country, especially Emma's morbid and annoying husband William.

The music too is beautiful. The best scene is when Vivien (Lady Hamilton) thinks she's left behind by Nelson; and then as the music soars in the violinistic passion, she rushes on to the balcony and finds him there. GORGEOUS!!! sob sob Esther's rating: 10

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:

Great flick

10/10
Author: (johnericketts@hotmail.com) from Whitefish Bay WI
15 August 2003

This is a great story with great acting and great dialog. Vivien Leigh was never more beautiful. The dying words of Lord Nelson are historically accurate; he really did speak repeatedly of Emma Hamilton, his lover in spite of being married.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 5 people found the following review useful:

That Frustrating Movie

7/10
Author: arieliondotcom from United States
17 November 2007

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This is an extremely frustrating movie, not because of the acting. Not even because of the script, especially considering the historical significance of the backstory (Winston commenting on Hitler in the form of Lord Nelson fighting Napoleon). But the camera work and, even worse, the directing is abominable.

The frustration comes from Olivier and Leigh literally not being in the same shot until halfway through the movie. Whenever you see the face of one, you are seeing the back of the other (if it is the other, it may even have been a stand-in). And so it's impossible to see the chemistry between them. Even in one hopeful scene where Leigh is running, running, running to him...Rather than getting the payoff of the two of them embracing and seeing the magic between them, you get only the back of Olivier's (or a stand-in's) head.

But finally, finally, literally in the middle of the movie, they come together in a kiss, a magnetic kiss that shows the power of the pull between them as well as the power of their acting.

The reason for the frustration is that this is the proving ground to show that Wuthering Heights, as wonderful as it was, wold have been immeasurably better with Leigh in the role of Catherine Earnshaw rather than Merle ("I chew furniture and call it acting") Oberon. Vivien Leigh IS Cathy, just as she is Scarlett O'Hara (who is, after all, just a shadow of Cathy). They are the same role, really, and Leigh would have bought all the power of her performance in Gone with the Wind to Wuthering Heights, and then some, stirred on by Olivier.

So, do see this movie. But not for the movie's sake. Treat yourself to another movie as you see this one. Realize how they would have been as Heathcliffe and Cathy, together, as they should have been.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 5 people found the following review useful:

As a hero, the real deal

9/10
Author: bkoganbing from Buffalo, New York
5 May 2005

Sir Laurence Olivier in his autobiography said that if he was to portray Horatio Nelson as his researches later showed, his Nelson would have been a far more complex and neurotic man who was going through what now would be described as a midlife crisis. That's not what the British public wanted in 1941 and Alexander Korda who shot the film in exile in America wasn't going to give them that.

Whatever the scandals of his private life as a seaman and a naval leader, Horatio Nelson was the real deal. One of the reasons I think he's come down that way in British history is for a most American of all reasons. He was a Horatio Alger success story. He was the son of an obscure country vicar who had way too many mouths to feed. Nelson's mom died while he was still a kid and he made the decision to go off to sea as a cabin boy. He rose in the ranks strictly on merit and talent and turned out to be the right man to save his country from certain invasion. Over 60 years later, Olivier's portrayal still rings true.

The real Emma Hamilton was shall we say, a bit more of a full figured gal than Vivien Leigh was and quite a bit more bawdy. The scenes where Nelson and the Hamiltons finally meet is one of the key ones. Emma's mother is delightfully played by Sara Allgood and as you see here at dinner with the Hamiltons and the Nelsons you appreciate where Emma's roots were, lower on the class scale than Nelson's.

Olivier and Leigh around the time of this film, got shed of their respective spouses and tied the knot. There's was a tempestuous marriage indeed, probably the kind that Nelson and Emma might have had if the opportunity came there way.

Of course Nelson living with the Hamiltons and openly flaunting their relationship scandalized Georgian society. The religious right would have a field day with him today, just as they did with Bill Clinton. Yet when Napoleon Bonaparte got his fleet put together and was sailing with the eventual invasion of Great Britain in mind, wasn't it funny that somehow no one really cared about Nelson's private life and just wanted the best man they had in the navy to save them. Nelson's life made a mockery of those no fraternization laws that the military hold so dear.

The other great British hero of the Napoleonic Wars was the Duke of Wellington. He did a stint as Prime Minister and became a controversial figure in his political career. One of the great speculations is if Nelson had not been killed at Trafalgar, repelling the French invasion, what kind of life he would have had. The Nelson here and in real life was not a political man, but like Dwight Eisenhower here, might have considered that career and who knows where he would have wound up on the issues that concerned Great Britain for the next couple of generations.

Larry and Viv head a remarkable group of players that bring to life the story of a most remarkable British hero.

Was the above review useful to you?

3 out of 5 people found the following review useful:

A bold romantic tale of stolen moments between star crossed lovers

10/10
Author: camibear7 from usa
11 May 2002

Vivian Leigh plays opposite her husband Laurence Olivier in this picturesque film set in the 1800's. Vivian plays Emma the part of a woman who has a rather unsavory past, who comes to Marsaille to live with the Ambassador there. Beautiful scenery sets the stage for a bold romantic tale of two people meeting quite by chance and how life changes for her as she is thrust into relationships with Royalty and a Captain Hamilton who's is fighting battles for the English Navy. It is a wonderful movie,exciting, extravagant, will hold your attention. Very enjoyable and will be a movie you will want to add to your library of films. I give this movie a "10".

Was the above review useful to you?

That Vivien Leigh woman

10/10
Author: jarrodmcdonald-1 from United States
1 March 2014

This picture emphasizes the fact that Vivien Leigh is not only beautiful but a major talent, too. In some ways, the character of Lady Emma Hamilton does resemble Leigh's earlier role of Scarlett O'Hara, but this is not surprising when one considers the actress is often typecast as the scheming vixen.

In a particularly memorable scene, when the Lady argues with her husband (Alan Mowbray) you do get a sense of Scarlett quarreling with Rhett. But the actress' undeniable chemistry with costar Laurence Olivier, as lover Lord Nelson, is perfect and much more intimate than what she shared on screen with Clark Gable in Gone with the Wind.

In fact, we believe that these two sincerely love each other. Both performers are rather eloquent and yet passionate in this film. And Korda's direction is superb. In addition to the great melodramatic moments, we are treated to some very realistic battle scenes that provide a fair amount of adventure amid the realities of war.

Was the above review useful to you?

Oh baby, blow off those cannons at me

7/10
Author: Alex da Silva from United Kingdom
18 June 2011

Vivien Leigh (Lady Hamilton) is caught shoplifting and put in a cell where she recounts her life story to Heather Angel. It's a story that reveals her to be the ex-mistress of Laurence Olivier (Lord Nelson) and ex-wife of Alan Mowbray (Lord Hamilton) and it details her romance with the English naval hero up until his death at the 'Battle of Trafalgar'.

The film is long but this doesn't seem to matter as the story captures the audience from the beginning. The scenes of Olivier in battle are redundant to the story - after all, it's meant to be about Lady Hamilton - and I suspect that they were only included to provide support for England in the battle against Nazi Hitler. There are certainly other flag-waiving moments such as the seamen speaking out the words of duty that are being sent by flag messages shortly before battle, and Olivier has a scene where he tells a room full of statesmen that you can only counter violence with violence. And he's quite right. If it wasn't for the war against Germany, these scenes could have been left out.

The cast are all good and mentions must go to Alan Mowbray who ends up as an hallucinating wreck and, in particular, Gladys Cooper (Lady Nelson) who holds a staggering dignity and whose every scene is filled with tension, especially those with Vivien Leigh. The friction between these two women is electric and it's because of Cooper.

There are some powerful scenes, eg, Vivien Leigh receiving the news of her lover's death, and the film gives you a bit of everything - romance, humour, drama and good actors. It ends rather suddenly - it would have been interesting to know what happens next and what happens to the child - but the story doesn't take things that far. Her story ends at the battle of Trafalgar. It would appear that she then just becomes the slag that she originally was.

Was the above review useful to you?

One of the great period pieces

8/10
Author: calvinnme from United States
21 November 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This is one of my favorite historic epic/romantic films. It stars Lawrence Olivier as Lord Nelson and Vivien Leigh as Emma Hart Hamilton, with Vivien Leigh fresh from her triumph in "Gone with the Wind" and at a time when the real-life romance and marriage between the two stars (Leigh and Olivier) was new.

The film is largely accurate, which is unusual for an historical drama of its time since these usually took great license with the truth. The departures from the truth that the film took were largely to satisfy the censors of the time. The truth is that William Hamilton, Emma's older husband, accepted and even encouraged the affair between his wife and Lord Nelson. When Emma set up housekeeping with Lord Nelson in England, William Hamilton lived there with them in a menage a trois relationship that fascinated the public of the time. In 1941 this would have been unacceptable on the screen.

The implication of the film is that Emma's daughter by Lord Nelson died. In fact their daughter married a man of the cloth, had ten children, and died at the age of 80. Emma's end as it is portrayed in the film is sadly accurate. Women of Emma's time were largely dependent upon their station in life and upon the whims of the men in their lives. If those men died, even if the man was great, women often found themselves in desperate poverty.

Was the above review useful to you?


Page 3 of 5: [Prev][1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [Next]

Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Plot synopsis Ratings
Awards External reviews Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history