The Iron Claw (1941) User Reviews

Brother Against Brother.....

[Mike-764 · 7/10 · 26 September 2004]

There are mighty strange goings on at Bensonhurst, secluded residence of Anton Benson a miserly recluse and his family including recently released convict Roy, daughter Millie, her husband Simon Leach, Dr. Roy Benson, and conniving brother Culver. All members of the family are searching for a stockpile of gold that Anton had recovered from a sunken Spanish ship, but murdered his way to get for himself. Also searching is the Iron Claw, a masked criminal who is one of the members of the Benson household. The Claw murders Culver and warns the rest of the members of the house that they may be next. Patricia, Anton's niece, works with reporter Bob Lane and photographer Jack Strong to uncover who the Claw is while trying to keep an eye on everyone in the house, as well as gangster Silk Langdon (working with Roy to get the gold) and butler Gyves, who is working hand in hand with Anton in order to grab all the gold for themselves. Its a fun serial, I'll grant that, but it could have been better. Quigley is very good as the hero (Lane) and Sande does pretty well as the semi-comic relief. Bryant seems just to scream a lot throughout the serial. I enjoy Charlie King in just about anything he did, so I won't complain about him as Langdon, and Willis is ever so shifty as Roy. Taylor is way over the top as Anton (James Craven must not have been available) and the other actors I could take or leave. Morton as Casey was a terrible character, but typical of a James Horne production. His direction is better than most of the Columbia serials he directed (also benefited by a good script with good touches of humor) on his own. The Iron Claw's identity isn't too hard to figure out, but he's a good character- always silent, he uses a lot of melodramatic, silent film era-esque motions. The serial does get repetitive after awhile going through one secret passage after another. Rating, based on serials, 7.

Not one of the best serials.

[Norm-30 · 3/10 · 8 September 2000]

If anyone has seen the intriguing still of the heroine in the clutches of the creepy-looking "Iron Claw", let me assure you that this serial doesn't live up to that.

It's a 15-Chapter serial (about 4 1/2 hours, running time) about a treasure in gold that's hidden the home of a miserly old man. His family (including the Iron Claw) is out to steal it from him. The first few chapters are pretty boring, with the family listening thru keyholes on each other, and the traditional "serial thrills" (cars going off cliffs, etc) are missing from this film. And, the heroine's fake "scream" (which is, unfortunately, all thru this film) drives you crazy after awhile.

All-in-all, the whole film is "muddled" and is an embarrassment to James Horne. Pass this one up and watch Quigley's classic "The Crimson Ghost" instead!

Norm

Could have been better

[jamesroyhold · 2/10 · 31 August 2019]

Extremely disappointing. The title character does not live up to his potential. With a name like the Iron Claw and possessing a metal hand you'd think he'd use that appendage for some gruesome chokings and beatings and stuff. He doesn't. In fact, the metal hand never comes into play. The heroine does nothing but scream. She's the most useless person ever in any serial. Most chapter plays have some sort of plot that moves along. This one simply rambles trying to fill the allotted time. All in all a waste of what could have been a fine villain.