IMDb > The Man from Tumbleweeds (1940) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Man from Tumbleweeds More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 7 reviews in total 

7 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

A Peaceable Man

6/10
Author: krorie from Van Buren, Arkansas
18 February 2006

Wild Bill Elliott, who got his moniker from playing Wild Bill Hickok in a popular serial, used the name Wild Bill Saunders in four films for Columbia. Wild Bill's trademark was wearing the two guns in his holster butt forward yet still drawing them in a traditional manner then swirling them around to put them back. Wild Bill was no phony. He was an expert horseman and had been since youth. Another trademark was calling himself a peaceable man yet using as much firepower as needed to knock down the bad guys.

This time around, Wild Bill attempts to put together a group of state rangers to clean up a band of outlaws led by the notorious Powder Kilgore (Ray Bennett) who lets one of his henchmen called Lightning (Francis Walker, not a name that invokes fear and dread) do his dirty work so he can stay free of the law. The outlaws work from a hideout which serves as a meeting house to plot and make plans for robbery of wagon trains operated by 'Spunky' Cameron (Iris Meredith) who has the hots for Wild Bill. In a novel twist at the time, Wild Bill hits on a ploy to use real-life killers who are incarcerated in the state prison to organize the rangers, since the governor is short on funds and willing gunslingers. This idea would reach its fruition in the hit movie "The Dirty Dozen" years later. Needless to say not all the criminals who are promised full pardons for their work are to be trusted. Some wise advice: Never trust a criminal who is called Shifty Sheldon. Wild Bill ultimately succeeds but not before a lot of action-packed adventure takes place. "Brother Bill" has a colorful exist on his paint as he rides out of town headed for Texas and more rip-snorting action leaving Spunky to dream about what could have been.

Cannonball (the redoubtable Dub Taylor) served as Wild Bill's comical sidekick in his Wild Bill Saunders films. He doesn't get to show his virtuosity on the xylophone this go around but has a few comic routines of note such as when he is "charred" by explosives when he throws them away from the jail house to save the day.

This Wild Bill outings has one major weakness. Though the story is a clever one, the script falters from time to time. There are plot holes aplenty and much is predictable. The lines given Wild Bill and Cannonball are at times somewhat silly. Otherwise, this is a fine Wild Bill Sauders flick.

Was the above review useful to you?

5 out of 6 people found the following review useful:

A fast early Joseph H. Lewis Western, a bit canned but well enough constructed

6/10
Author: secondtake from United States
31 March 2011

The Man from Tumbleweeds (1940)

The claim to fame here is slight--it's directed by Joseph H. Lewis, later famous for some inventive, raw low budget movies like "Gun Crazy" (1951). It is directed with his usual fast, visual panache, though he's inexperienced here and it shows. The script is pretty routine, too, and so when the dialog intrudes, it intrudes.

But it's fast, there are several turns of events, one of the main characters is a woman sheriff, and there are lots of gun fights, horse chases, double crossing, and broad black and white landscape. I liked it more than I should have, and it's partly how really well it was directed. With better actors and better dialog, this would easily be memorable.

This is one in a series of one hour Westerns starring actor Bill Elliott, a sheriff who loved to be violent to bring in the bad guys, and would say, "Some folks call me Wild Bill. But I'm a peaceable man." It's the only Elliott film Lewis directed.

Elliott was an Old West kind of character himself, and was the lead in several movie (low budget) serials, playing detective Gordon Elliott in some 28 of them, then a turning point came when Elliott (as Gordon Elliott) played Wild Bill Hickcok, the historical figure as portrayed in the 1938 movie. After this he played in Westerns for two decades. In the first four in the series, he played Wild Bill Saunders, and this is the third of them, all for Columbia Pictures. Then he switched to the more famous Wild Bill Hickcock himself for 12 films. When he moved to Republic pictures he starred as himself, Wild Bill Elliott.

Should you see this? Why not? It's nothing much, but it's not bad, if you like Westerns of this sort. Any John Ford movie is better, of course, but this short and exciting. Oh, and don't be fooled by the opening credit that says Hygo Television Films--that was added for the 1953 re-release for t.v.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Long before "The Dirty Dozen" pardoned prisoners for duty, this little western championed that plot idea

6/10
Author: zardoz-13 from United States
11 September 2005

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Despite its low-budget B-movie origins and its brisk 59-minute running time, this Wild Bill Elliot horse opera qualifies as one of the earliest examples of a movie where society enlists convicts to establish law and order to the frontier west. Typically, most moviegoers think that "The Dirty Dozen" introduced the parole-the-prisoners plot, but this 1940 sagebrusher used that idea long before director Robert Aldrich appropriated it for his anti-heroic, behind-enemy-lines, World War II-themed blockbuster. In fact, the parole-the-prisoners plot turned up earlier in Burt Kennedy's western sequel "Return of the Seven" (1966), Roger Corman's behind enemy lines W.W. 2 opus "The Secret Invasion" (1964), and Richard Bartlett's "Two-Gun Lady" (1956).

When trigger-happy outlaws lay down the rule of lawlessness in the town of Gun Sight by the, two-gun toting Bill Saunders (Bill Elliot) rides to the rescue. "My name's Wild Bill, but I'm a peaceable man," says Bill to just about everybody. Unlike most western champions, Bill packs his brace of pistols in his holsters with the handles reversed so the hammers face away from him when he draws. Kilgore (Ray Bennett) and his gang of henchmen have been hijacking wagon trains as free and easy as hawks until 'Spunky' Cameron (western heroine regular Iris Meredith), daughter of wagon train boss Jeff Cameron, sends Cannonball (veteran western sidekick Dub Taylor of "Bandolero") to find Wild Bill to restore order. As a tough-as-nails villain, Kilgore proves his credentials from the get-go by gunning down old Jeff on Main Street in broad daylight. Unfortunately, since Jeff (Edward LeSaint of "The Green Hornet") shucked his six-shooter first, Kilgore cannot be arrested for what constitutes 'self-defense.' Meantime, Cannonball hightails it to another dusty western hamlet just in time to watch Wild Bill foil a bank robbery single-handedly against three armed assailants. Cannonball brings Bill and Spunky together to discuss the lawlessness, and Bill visits Governor Dawson (Don Beddoe of "Night of the Hunter") to round up some gunmen to create a state police to hunt down these hooligans. Dawson explains to Will Bill that the legislature has wrapped his plans up in red tape so he hasn't had any luck. Wild Bill proposes another plan: release some of the deadliest six-gunners in prison into his custody to flush out the bad guys and award the convicts with paroles if they help him corral these heavies. Of course, everything works out in the long run, but there are a couple of surprises along the way. Director Joseph H. Lewis, who later went on to fame directing TV westerns like "Bonanza," "Branded," "The Rifleman," and "The Big Valley," keeps things moving at a swift clip. The only drawback is during a stagecoach shoot-out several gunhands believe that they are bulletproof enough to stand out in the open and swap lead without consequences. Later, the much talking about but hard to locate secret hideout that Kilgore and his men operate out of is neither as secret nor as exotic as the secret hideout in most westerns like the 1954 Nicholas Ray oater "Johnny Guitar", but then the low budget accounts for that shortcoming. Scenarist Charles F. Royal's screenplay for "The Man from Tumbleweeds" is again one of the earliest examples of a Hollywood movie where the heroes have to rely on henchmen fresh out of prison to help them. Royal's dialogue is worth quoting, too.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

"This is one roundup that one cowpoke can't handle alone".

6/10
Author: classicsoncall from Florida, New York
3 July 2011

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Gordon Nance appeared in a boatload of Westerns using the character name of Wild Bill - there was Wild Bill Hickok and Wild Bill Elliott, but for a brief four picture series with Columbia in 1940 he was Wild Bill Saunders. As "The Man From Tumbleweeds", Bill prevails upon Governor Dawson (Don Beddoe) to put together a lawman posse out of seven prisoners released to his custody to take on the Powder Kilgore (Ray Bennett) gang operating in the environs of Gun Sight. This is a fairly standard oater given the nature of these B Westerns, but trivia fans will find a number of interesting points to ponder with this film.

For starters, there's Bill's sidekick Cannonball, portrayed by comic relief character actor Dub Taylor. Taylor had the name Cannonball Simms in his prior Columbia team-up with Elliott, "Pioneers of the Frontier", but apparently the last name was dropped in the other three pictures. Taylor uses some of the same type of braggadocio to describe his past exploits the way Gabby Hayes would in any number of his movie Westerns backing up stars like Roy Rogers. Cannonball's high spot in this flick occurs when he throws a makeshift bomb away from the Gun Sight town jail, and winds up in black face when the bomb explodes off screen. A few years later, Dub would appear with Charles Starrett in his Durango Kid films going by the name of Cannonball Taylor.

During his days at Columbia and Republic, Elliott rode a number of different paint horses, all going by the name of Sonny. In this picture, it looks like he's aboard the original Sonny, identified by the white spot on the forehead, and more noticeably, the bi-colored black and white mane and tail. The name Sonny isn't mentioned by name in the story, but I do believe I heard Cannonball call his horse Jim.

I got a kick out of some of the names given the outlaws who were sprung from prison to accompany Saunders. There was Shifty, Slash and Honest John identified immediately, but you had to stay attentive to catch the rest - Blackie, Daggett and Flint. I didn't catch the last one if it was mentioned, and most of them don't appear in the credits, which isn't unusual for these pictures.

I guess I shouldn't forget actress Iris Meredith appearing as Cameron Freight operator Spunky Cameron. She has a role in nabbing the bad guys along with Cannonball and the rest, all with an eye it seems on roping Wild Bill by the end of the story. But not this jack rabbit, Bill was already making plans to high tail it to Texas for his next adventure. The head of the newly formed state rangers would have to be Honest John Webster (Al Hill), who performed admirably as Saunders' next in command. What would you expect of a guy named Honest John?

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Wild Bill to the Rescue

6/10
Author: dougdoepke from Claremont, USA
2 May 2011

There's lots of six-gun action and hard riding with more intrigue than usual for a matinée entry. Crime boss Kilgore is pillaging the state until Wild Bill arrives to head up a ranger force recruited from the state prison. Everybody's got a sneaky plan to nail the opposition. Add a tricky informant who goes back and forth between the sides, and you may need a scorecard.

Elliot is really good at being tough and even downright mean when the occasion calls for it. In my book, he's one of the few matinée heroes who could also play a bad guy as well as a good. Here, however, he stays pretty nice, but is still convincing as the head ranger. Pretty girl Meredith gets more plot than usual for pretty girls and even gets to sling a gun at the bad guys.

Of course, no one expects high drama from these matinée specials. Still, this one's notable for its cult director, Joseph H. Lewis, who was clearly perfecting his technique with crashing windows and complex plots. Too bad the action itself never gets out of the scrubby LA area, but Lewis makes good use of what he's got. Okay, this former Front Row kid still looks at these oaters with 12-year old eyes, so I'm probably not the best critic. But I still think it delivers the goods for old time fans.

Was the above review useful to you?

Excellent cast in pretty good story is still pretty slow

7/10
Author: Michael Morrison (morrisonhimself@consultant.com) from Arizona
11 April 2016

Gordon Elliott became Wild Bill Elliott and was generally a good cowboy and generally his name meant an at least pretty good movie.

"The Man from Tumbleweeds" is barely a pretty good movie.

It was populated by some great cowboy performers, and even Dub "Cannonball" Taylor wasn't over the top.

But it was awfully slow.

The story, the premise was a good one, but somehow, despite some very good scenes and some good dialogue, ultimately it was rather lame, even trite.

Everything was fairly predictable, except there was not a final blood-bath as might be expected in a low-budget movie.

If you're a Western fan, you do want to see it, and I hope you like it better than this review might lead you to. It's available in a somewhat out of focus print at YouTube.

Was the above review useful to you?

0 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

"I've Got Jackrabbits in my Boots"

5/10
Author: bkoganbing from Buffalo, New York
22 June 2011

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

With that phrase Wild Bill Elliott playing Wild Bill Saunders again states why he just can't settle down in any one place. Elliott's Saunders character is a Lone Ranger without a mask, going all over the west, righting whatever wrongs there are in a given area.

In this case Elliott gets a commission from Governor Don Beddoe no less when he sells him on the idea of establishing a state ranger force. Local law enforcement is unable to deal with roving gangs of outlaws who jump from county to county. Elliott even sells Beddoe on the idea of paroling some hard cases from the state penitentiary to clean up a certain really bad gang who murdered freighter Edward LeSaint in front of his daughter Iris Meredith. Get this bunch and a pardon might be in the offing and these paroled convicts the nucleus for a permanent state rangers.

One thing really kind of got me. Granted that this film is for the Saturday matinée crowd of kids. But are we really surprised when one of Elliott's parolees turns out to be a double agent when he's got a nickname of Shifty? These films are never known for subtlety.

I'm sure the kids in gallery got their money's worth from The Man From Tumbleweeds.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings External reviews
Plot keywords Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history