Lying Lips (1939) User Reviews

Positives about Lying Lips

[elegant_ms04 · 6/10 · 5 April 2005]

I thought this was a good film considering the time in which it was shot and the low budget Micheaux had to work with. He was a pioneer for other African American film makers including Spike Lee and Robert Townsend. Though the acting is not superior,this was the best we could get at the time. This was one of the few times that African Americans were able to see others on the screen that actually looked like them, without donning black face. We as modern day viewers can not appreciate how much went into a film; as we are used to films with lighting effects, soundtracks, multi-million dollar budgets, and lucrative distribution deals. Micheaux set the pace early in the film game and many others are following his lead.

Probably one of the best completely flawed movies I've ever seen.

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 6 July 2022]

A lot of the script is laughably trite, and some of the acting is less than praiseworthy. That issue is due to some poor choices in the direction by Oscar Micheaux. But there's so much in spite of all those things that is definitely worth acclaim, from the great staging of the musical numbers in between the drama to the charm of the cast as a whole (even if some of their acting isn't all that great), and the fact that many of these performers will be recognizable for things they did many years later. The story is quite good. Edna Mae Harris plays a nightclub singer who refuses to play ball with the white owners of the club she works at by entertaining customers afterwards, and ends up being framed for the murder of her aunt. Dancer Carman Newsome stands by her throughout, and detective Robert Earl Jones vows to find out the truth.

While Harris often speaks her lines in a monotonous way, she has a sweetness and charm that shines through that, and she certainly can put over a song. Frances Williams, as a distant relative who also works at the club, is terrific. Fans of "Designing Women" will recognize her as Anthony's grandmother, and it should be noted her importance in civil rights issues from a young age.

Earl Jones, father of James, looks very similar to his famous son, and is just as terrific an actor. Juano Hernandez as the reverend is another familiar character actor, also groundbreaking in furthering advancements for black artists. This is definitely a film that has a lot of good going for it in spite of the weaknesses, and deserves its place on the National registry. The print I saw was pristine, and it's a shame that they didn't take more time to work out the flaws and that it came out of time when this could not have had a big wide screen release.

Important but Bland

[Michael_Elliott · 26 February 2008]

Lying Lips (1939)

** (out of 4)

Rather bizarre murder mystery from director Oscar Micheaux who's best remembered for Within Our Gates. An innocent woman (Edna Mae Harris) is sent to prison for murdering her aunt while her best friend and a Detective (Robert Earl Jones) try to find the real killers. This was my third film by the director but the first sound feature. His direction is pretty good throughout but you really have to question his screenplay, which starts off rather silly and just gets stranger from there. The case is eventually cracked when the Detective takes one man to a haunted house so that a ghost will scare the truth out of him. The performances are all pretty bad and yes, that Robert Earl Jones is the father of James Earl Jones.

Terrible acting make it unwatchable

[eisucks · 1/10 · 20 October 2004]

Words cannot describe how horrendous the acting in this movie was. The methods of actors have, over the years, improved by leaps and bounds. Now I'm not one of those people who can't stand all actors form the first half of the century. Even I know that back in the 1930s and 40s there were people who understood the craft. However, Edna Mae Harris is not one of those people. She gives a performance so atrocious, it baffles me that she ever worked again. Not only her, but every other actor who appears on screen (with the exception of Robert Earl Jones) couldn't act themself out of a paper bag. In addition to the bad acting, the film is also marred by sloppy editing and poor direction. Considering the other cinematic achievements of Oscar Micheaux, one would expect more from him. "Lying Lips" was easily one of the hardest movies I've ever had the misfortune of sitting through.

FINAL VERDICT: 1/10

Hello? Hello? Hell-o? Hello? Hello? Hello?

[Spuzzlightyear · 3/10 · 26 October 2005]

One of the best funny/bad movies I have seen in a long time, 'Lying Lips' is a simple yarn (with a pretty stupid ending that takes 5 minutes to explain) about a woman who is framed with her Aunt's murder. Lying Lips also presents us with the attempted acting skills of one Edna Mae Harris. Her singing is not bad, but when she's forced to act, her line delivery is so hilariously bad I was falling off the floor laughing. Even worse is the dialogue. For some odd reason, the director made the cops as stupid as possible. Check the interrogation scene. EVERYTHING is repeated twice, and sometimes three times! "I answered the phone" "You answered the phone?" "I Answered The Phone" "I went back to the phone!" "So you went back to the phone?" "I went back to the phone!" Also the police are very smart: Witness: "She was my cousin!" Police Chief: "Oh she was your cousin! So you were related!" Also, people have made comments about Earl Jones' performance. I thought he was so stilted, just barking out his lines to the point of hilarity! Much much more to be found in this film: Edna Mae taking a bath apparently with her heels on, her poor attempts at screaming and fainting, her reaction when someone answers the phone, (see the title of my review for an explanation of this), her schizophrenic bath habits, the laughable continuity, the laughable editing, clubs that have wooden doors and no signage, and a white police chief who say he's glad a black policeman is helping to solve who killed a black woman because "being a colored man, he might find things our other officers could not!" A Hoot!

Oscar Micheaux's Lying Lips is pretty entertaining despite some stilted dialogue

[tavm · 7/10 · 8 February 2011]

In celebrating the film achievements of people of color for Black History Month in chronological order on my itinerary, we're now in 1939 when writer/producer/director Oscar Micheaux brought back some cast members from his previous movies for the one I'm reviewing here. Among them: Carman Newsome (Swing!, God's Step Children), Amanda Randolph (also Swing!), and Juano Hernandez (The Girl from Chicago). There are also a couple of cast members from The Green Pastures (Edna Mae Harris, Slim Thomson). Incidentally, I also saw Thomson in Edgar Ulmer's Moon Over Harlem. This picture also marked the debut of one Robert Earl Jones, James Earl Jones' father. Also, Ms. Randolph is the sister of Lillian Randolph, another player from my favorite movie-It's a Wonderful Life. With that out of the way, I'll just say this murder mystery is pretty interesting plot-wise though the dialogue is stilted especially the way the actors deliver them. Why, I laughed when the Jones character said, "That just makes my blood boil!" But, like I said, I liked the plot and I especially loved the many musical numbers that made up the first 45 minutes of the movie especially when Ms. Harris sang "You Must Have Been a Beautiful Baby". She may not have been a great actress but she sure was a fine singer and dancer. So on that note, I'll say Lying Lips is at the least worth a look.

James Earl Jones's dad, such a cool find

[willandcharlenebrown · 8/10 · 13 October 2021]

I think this is a great find! Seeing African Americans in roles like detectives back in 1939 when they couldn't even use the same drinking fountain is awesome! It has some bad acting for sure haha but again..... nice find of a movie.