12 reviews in total
6 out of 17 people found the following review useful:
Very difficult to finish watching...this is simply a bad film from Hollywood's otherwise golden age.
planktonrules from Bradenton, Florida
3 May 2007
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
This is a poor film for so many, many reasons and I was shocked to see
SOME reviewers who gave it a 10! Do they seriously think this film is
as good or better than CITIZEN KANE, CASABLANCA or ORDINARY PEOPLE?
Yes, it's fine if you liked the film, but to give it a 10 sets up some
amazingly high expectations and I really think this film, on a generous
day, MIGHT earn a 5, as it was very poorly written, the acting and
accents were at times terrible and the romance completely hokey and
A big part of the problem was that the film was set at a "Borscht Belt"
resort in the Catskills, but it was so sanitized that it gave a
superficial view at best. Let me explain with a little bit of
background. In the first half (or more) of the 20th century, many
Jewish families went to these mountain resorts for vacations--partly
for the fun and partly because, unfortunately, Jews were made to feel
unwelcome at all the other resorts (some even banned Jews and other
"undesireables"). These Borscht Belt resorts featured hiking, camping,
canoing as well as lots of entertainment by Jewish performers who would
later go on to stardom as comedians--such as Milton Berle, Woody Allen,
Mel Brooks, Morey Amsterdam and Rodney Dangerfield (among MANY others).
While I was NOT hoping to see over the top Jewish accents and overly
stereotyped images, this film featured Ginger Rogers in the lead (one
of the least Jewish-looking actresses of the time) and some bizarre
Jewish-like accents that frankly were ridiculous (particularly Eve
Arden's). The overall effect only bears a vague resemblance to the
Borscht Belt--the way that Amos and Andy bore a resemblance to Black
America (especially the radio version of the show)! Why not instead use
more Jewish actors and have them just be themselves? Perhaps Hollywood
thought Americans at the time would not accept this, so they created a
bland and Wasp-y version with only a token Jew that might be more
acceptable to the common person.
Regardless of the sanitized nature of the film, the romance and acting
were poor and clichéd. When Ginger met handsome Douglas Fairbanks, Jr.,
you KNEW exactly where the film would go and their antics became pretty
annoying. In fact, the film itself was loud, obnoxious and about as
subtle as a 2x4 upside your head! Plus, male camp workers uttering
lines such as "what a pack of dogs" as the female vacationers got off
the buses was rather awful because it was meant to be funny. Aside from
a few scenes from Red Skelton which some might find funny (I didn't),
the film was neither funny nor romantic--clearly a misfire.
7 out of 20 people found the following review useful:
not so good
16 July 2002
Dull and uninvolving with scenes that play out too long. The basic premise
of a secretary on vacation falling in love with a waiter at the lodge is
interesting but is not explored to its full extent; and despite good
performances, laughs are far between.
Add another review