Ulmer's soulful, open-air adaptation of Peretz Hirshbein's classic play heralded the Golden Age of Yiddish cinema. When an ascetic young scholar ventures into the countryside, searching for... See full summary »
Many passengers on the Shanghai Express are more concerned that the notorious Shanghai Lil is on board than the fact that a civil war is going on that may make the trip take more than three... See full summary »
Josef von Sternberg
Anna May Wong
Horace Vendig shows himself to the world as a rich philanthropist. In fact, the history of his rise from his unhappy broken home shows this to be far from the case. After being taken in by ... See full summary »
A group of men calling themselves 'The Pirates of Capri", headed by Captain Sirroco, who is really Count Amalfi, are trying to restore freedom to the people of Naples in 1799. The Queen is ... See full summary »
Edgar G. Ulmer,
Giuseppe Maria Scotese
Nat Silver has been engaged 7 times already. This time, his 8th, he's really going to get married. But a visitor shows up, Shirley's old boyfriend. With a gun ! He'll kill himself unless he... See full summary »
Edgar G. Ulmer
A young, classical-trained musician, Peter Crane, transfers from the Conservatory to Clinton High School, where he finds his music in conflict to that of the high school's world of jive and... See full summary »
Ulmer's soulful, open-air adaptation of Peretz Hirshbein's classic play heralded the Golden Age of Yiddish cinema. When an ascetic young scholar ventures into the countryside, searching for the city of "true Jews," he learns some unexpected lessons from the Jewish peasants who take him in as a tutor for their children. Written by
National Center for Jewish Film
The film was shot in five days after six weeks of rehearsal. Director Edgar G. Ulmer said in an interview that the producers raised the money ($8,000) for the film by hocking furniture. When the film laboratory threatened to foreclose on the film because they hadn't been paid, the head of the International Ladies' Garment Workers Union, David Dubinsky, purchased 75,000 tickets in advance, after he saw and liked a rough cut of the film. See more »
Restored by the National Center for Jewish Films and the American Jewish Historical Society, with funding from the National Endowment for the Arts, this 1938 film is co-directed by Jacob Ben-Ami who was an important figure in Yiddish theatre, and film-maker Edgar G Ulmer.
The screenplay is based on the popular play by Peretz Hirschbein, a writer who was interested in presenting the rural communities and traditional life of East-European Jews of Poland, Russia and the Ukraine which began to disappear at the turn of the century when Jews became more secularised and emigrated to more hospitable urban areas. The play was produced in 1923, with Hirshbein's view idyllising the old way of life, with the production filmed in New Jersey countryside on a shoe-string budget.
The narrative of a yeshiva student leaving his synagogue to find "truth", stems from a repeated quote from the Torah "A man without land is not a man. Heaven is the Lord's heaven and he has given the earth unto man". This philosophy prepares us for a paean to the working classes, here represented as neighbouring peasants who squabble over whose house the student will live in, and whose children gossip about kisses and romance. The fact that they view the student with awe, as an intelletual and therefore superior to them, is a lesson for the student. He must overlook their pettiness and stupidity, to learn that "The Lord desires both Torah and the land".
The idea of a peasant's daughter having a romantic interest in the student at first seems odd, particularly as he is posed the way Jesus Christ is posed in standard Hollywood Christian film. We see that rural female are outspoken and sexually aggressive, but the student is noticeably asexual, physically weak, and rocks neurotically back and forth even when not praying. When the daughter suggests she study with him, the way a boy is, we have a touch of the progressive feminist Yentl, until we realise it is only a feminine ruse.
Perhaps one has to make a dated concession for the material, but modern audiences read the drama as low comedy. The only interesting features are the specific rituals eg the girl's mother telling her to dress modestly "or he won't even look at you", how being barefoot is forbidden, and especially how the mother breathes on her daughter's forehead then spits, presumably a wish of good fortune.
That the actors come from a Yiddish theatre background thankfully doesn't mean we get over-acting. However one is surprised to hear that the student has been with one family for a month, as the passage of time is not shown.
Visually the direction often draws attention to the stage origins, with the camera at audience level to be able to take in the group of people talking.
That this is said to be the only fully restored Yiddish film in existence is a tribute. One only wishes the material wasn't so disappointing. If you consider the same play in a Goy millieu, (this isn't being anti-semitic, I hope, because Jews aren't the only people with vanished communities), one would have less reason for celebration.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?