Paul Scheer sheds some light on The Room, lets us in on a secret in The Disaster Artist, and answers your questions. Plus, we explore the origins of midnight movies and take a look at IMDb's Top 10 Stars of 2017.
The police find the actress, Diana Baring, near the body of her friend. All the circumstantial proofs seems to point to her and, at the end of the trial, she is condemned. Sir John Menier, a jury member, suspects Diana's boyfriend, who works as an acrobat wearing a dresses. Written by
Claudio Sandrini <email@example.com>
Miles Mander and Esme V. Chaplin are the only actors to appear in its German language remake Mary (1931). Mander reprised his role as Gordon Druce, though the character's name was changed to Gordon Moore, while Esme V. Chaplin plays the prosecuting counsel in both films. See more »
When Sir John interviews Diana in jail, they are shown sitting at opposite ends of a table in long-shot. The widths of the planks that make up the tabletop reveal that, in closeups, they are both seated at the same end of the table. See more »
People ought to be ashamed of themselves, kicking up all that racket at this time of night.
See more »
In an early depiction of Hitchcock's fear and mistrust of the police
and the legal system, we have a very legal thriller about a murder and
it's subsequent trial. We are given the facts of the case, even a sort
of a limited view of the murder itself taking place, followed by the
prosecution and defense presenting their cases at the trial and a
detailed look at the jury's discussion of the case. Sort of Hitchcock's
version of 12 Angry Men.
There is a curious cast of characters involved in the film, and two of
Hitch's biggest interests, the law and the arts, are on center stage.
Sir John in the single character who takes the time to really look
deeply into what really happened that night, even though someone's life
is on the line based on the verdict that they reach, and his personal
investigation is probably the best part of the film. One of the things
that this movie is famous for is for being the first film where
someone's thoughts are shown in a film, in the scene where he is
looking at himself in the mirror, shaving. For this scene, a recording
of him speaking was played off screen, since vocals could not be added
to the film later.
There is a scene in the film where Mr. Marlowe goes to visit Sir John
at his request, and as he approaches Sir John's desk there is a close
up of his feet, which sink deeply into the rug as though it were laid
over a soft mattress. This is never explained, although I am willing to
accept that this is a spot of symbolism the meaning of which escaped
me, since so much of the rest of the film is deeply layered, literally
and figuratively, as well. There is an astonishing amount of technique
and content to be seen here, impossible to catch all in one viewing,
which is one sign of a great film.
Some editing and filming techniques I suspect were not as successful as
they seemed in the writing stages, but the film is strong nonetheless.
Consider, for example, the brave and highly successful technique of
lingering on the empty jury room while the verdict is read offstage,
and the shockingly effective technique of having the face of the victim
hanging in the vision of the murderer. Incredibly, I think this is one
of the single most haunting shots I have ever seen in a Hitchcock film.
It has its slow moments and may be a bit longer than it's content can
support, but this is a brilliant example of Hitch's early work.
Also keep your eye out for Hitchcock's cameo, which is a full hour into
the film. This was long before he began putting all of his cameos in
the beginnings of his films, knowing that the audience would be
watching for him and not wanting this to distract from the stories.
17 of 21 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?