The Song Is Ended (1930) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Another charming Willi Forst film! Romance, wit, comedy like Wilder & Lubitsch!
larry41onEbay19 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I don't want to spoil the plot by telling you too much, only I recommend this film to anyone who likes Billy Wilder (who was a good friend of Willi Forst) or Ernst Lubitsch (another wit that liked little surprises thru out his films.

SPOILERS:

"Every time Liane Haid appears in a German film she seems more charming than ever. Such was the case when this excellent actress played the starring role, with Willy Forst, in "The Song Is Ended." In fact, one of the main reasons against this piece being taken seriously by a well-pleased audience was the difficulty of believing that any live young man could have resisted her wiles as long as Ulrich Weidenau, her private secretary, did.

Forst is very good as the former army officer glad to get a job as secretary to the operetta singer whose feelings he has hurt a few nights before by abruptly in a cafe while she is singing a song about an imaginary officer. When the Baron, the Publisher and rich young Toenli, all more or less in love with Tilla, fail to run down the guilty wretch, she temperamentally dismisses them and hires a private secretary who of course, is Herr Weidenau himself. The great Tilla at once falls head over heels in love with her humble, but likely, employee, but he holds aloof in spite of his speedy infatuation until the last minute of the story.

The picture is filled with all sorts of amusing situations and has at least two songs that will linger in the spectator's memory for some time. They are sung very well. The supporting cast is capable and the photography and direction good." This film is available on DVD with switchable English subtitles, I recommend it!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not as good as the 1933 British remake (The Song you Gave Me)
RKO-Komyathy23 February 2021
Best song: 'Frag' nicht Warum' (Don't ask me why) Performer: Marcel Wittrisch

This German language movie was remade in 1933 with Bebe Daniels in the lead versus Liane Haid in this production. It is impossible not to compare them as 90% of these movies are not just similar but almost the same (many scenes are short the exact same way with almost the same dialogue and both films use the exact same Marionette show footage).

You may be saying, consequently, that the British remake just copied this film. Well, yes and no. The issue with this German production is that the plot centers around a rich woman attracted to a relatively poor man but the actor (Willi Forst) playing this role comes across as a young John Mills (capable, smart, handsome and one who can sing), whereas in the 1933 version this role was played by Hungarian Victor Varconi. Varconi comes across as an old Europe sophisticated gentleman, albeit poor and he does a great job balancing his desires and lack of expectations.

In short, it almost is not believable that the very sophisticated Liane Haid could fall for the poor character portrayed ably by Willi Forst. Bebe Daniels plays her role with a bit less sophistication and Hungarian Victor Varconi (who made about 75 silent pictures in Europe) comes across as sophisticated to possible bridge this gap between the two leads.

If such is your inclination watch both and the fact that the endings of these two movies differs would allow you to do that quite easily.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed