Railroadin' (1929) User Reviews

Second all-talking "Our Gang" film

[jimtinder · 8/10 · 10 February 2001]

"Railroadin'", the second "Our Gang" talkie, was believed to exist only in silent form prior to the late 1970s. In 1929, sound on disc, rather than sound on film, was the more widely accepted method of making talking pictures. As a result, many early talkies suffer from the hiss and scratches and pops associated with sound discs. Also, over time, these sound discs could be broken or lost, resulting in the talkie becoming a silent film forever. For almost fifty years, the sound discs to "Railroadin'" were believed to have met this fate.

Happily, this was not to be the case with "Railroadin'." Blackhawk had prepared a silent version with titles for home movie use, but in the late 1970s, a "Railroadin'" sound disc was discovered and synched with the film by Blackhawk, and later released on video.

"Railroadin's" sound disc does show the wear and tear of time, and some of the dialogue is difficult to discern. That does not deter from the enjoyment of the film, however. "Railroadin'" is thoroughly enjoyable and its fun to watch the kids cavort in a railroad roundhouse.

What is amazing about "Railroadin'" is that in some scenes, the train seems to actually run over Farina! In distance shots a dummy was used, but in the close ups it's really Farina. These scenes were probably filmed with the train moving over him very slowly, and Farina was probably in a small pit. The scenes, though, are very realistic.

"Railroadin'" is as good as the 1929-30 talkie "Our Gang" films get. Solid and clean entertainment for the whole family. 8 out of 10.

Runaway Train

[ccthemovieman-1 · 8/10 · 1 April 2010]

The second talkie in the long-run "Our Gang" series really kicks into high gear when the train a few of the kids are running goes out of control, speeding down the tracks. This dramatic "runaway train" segment comprises the second half of this 21-minute film.

During the train-out-control segment, Farina gets "run over" about a half-dozen times. Actually, and it shows this, he lies down flat just before the train arrives, so it passes over the top of him each time.

In all, in what starts off as a leisurely-paced story of kids learning about trains, turns into a dramatic story in which the kids - and passengers of on coming train - nearly lose their lives.

For those who love trains, there are some great closeup shots of these fantastic machines. This turned out to be a very entertaining early Our Gang short.

The Little Rascals in a runaway train

[robert-temple-1 · 8/10 · 21 July 2017]

There are plenty of hair-raising thrills and spills in this second Little Rascals sound film. The orphanage from which they came is now left far behind, and we see none of the adoptive mothers in this film either. The film takes place entirely in a rail yard and along the rail tracks leading from it. The film begins with Farina and Harry playing on a railway turntable in the rail yard. Then the little fat boy Joe, and a new friend of his who is also a little fat boy, Chubby (though we do not hear his name mentioned, played by Norman Chaney), bringing sandwiches in their metal lunch boxes to their fathers (Joe's being adoptive) who are railway engineers who operate a locomotive. Joe's father invites the boys up into the locomotive to see all the levers and controls, and permits Joe to blow the horn. They all then leave the locomotive and go to a bench where the men sit and eat their lunch. Meanwhile, the other five Little Rascals plus Pete the Dog are also playing in the rail yard. They have put together an elaborate den for themselves in an empty rail freight car which has no roof. It rests on a side track, far behind and not attached to the resting locomotive. Mischief begins when Joe and Chubby leave their fathers and go back to the train and climb up into the locomotive again. They fiddle a bit with some controls, but do not know how to start the train. The rail yard has been plagued for some time by a former rail worker who has gone mad, and who hangs around leering at people. He spots the boys in the locomotive and climbs in with them. He starts the locomotive for them and then leaps out. The only lever Joe knows how to control is one which causes the train to reverse its direction. The train moves ominously forward and in panic, Joe reverses its direction, so that it begins to go backwards towards the freight car where the other Rascals are playing. Joe reverses direction just before crashing into them. Meanwhile Farina has caught his foot in a switch and is sitting on the track helplessly in front of the oncoming locomotive. He sees it coming, puts his hands together in prayer and says 'Now I lay me down to sleep …' Then he leans back flat and the locomotive passes over him, leaving him unharmed. Joe reverses again and it passes over Farina in the other direction, and this happens several times. Harry comes to free his foot and says: 'How come the locomotive passed right over you and you ain't dead?' And then Joe fails to reverse in time and the locomotive does collide with the freight car, so that it becomes attached to the locomotive, with the children in it. Then he successfully reverses and begins to move forward at increasing speed, and they go through the town and into the countryside on the wild runaway train, with numerous cars and even a streetcar narrowly missing them at crossings. Then another trains carrying passengers is coming straight at them and disaster is narrowly averted by a quick-thinking signalman who pulls a switch for the passenger train to divert it at the last second. All of these goings-on are very much in the tradition of the silent films, such as Buster Keaton's, with split-second escapes and terrifying near misses. Eventually the locomotive is brought under control and the Rascals are returned to the rail yard, which they say they will avoid in the future. Farina then has some further adventures of his own, for which the viewer must remain in suspense, but I will give one cue: what comes first, the chicken or the egg? It is not always possible to make out what the children are saying in this film, the most difficult to understand being Harry and occasionally Farina. Pete the Dog is a passive participant in this episode, suffering the indignities of collisions with his commendable canine passivity. Truly, he was the Marguerite Dumont of the cinema dog world. This film is only 20 minutes long, five minutes shorter than its predecessor, SMALL TALK.

Interesting note on job prospects for Black Americans in 1929

[G. R. · 1 November 2004]

It's been noted that the sound track of "Railroadin' " is difficult to hear. I FINALLY figured out what Farina said after the gang had finished admiring all of the locomotives at the roundhouse. This is early in the film. What he had to say was quite a statement on the prospects of what kind a job a young, black kid might find. His white companions stated something to the effect, I'm going to be an engineer and drive that" Farina, on the other hand, declared, "Well, I'm gonna change my name to GEORGE and be a porter!" ALL porters on the railroad in those days were referred to as "George".

Fascinating little film being a railroad fan and employee. AT&SF RR historians will like seeing the Santa Fe equipment. (They tried to cover over the names.)

Playin' On Trains With The Little Rascals

[Ron Oliver · 7/10 · 17 June 2000]

An OUR GANG Comedy Short.

While playing in the train yard, Fat Joe Cobb, Farina & the Gang go RAILROADIN' in a runaway train, which none of them knows how to stop...

A funny little early talkie. Due to its age, some of the dialogue is difficult to hear. Highlight: Farina on the tracks. Fat Joe & Chubby are so obese it's painful to watch them.

Keaton, Lloyd, Chaplin... Farina

[huboon · 9/10 · 1 June 2003]

Joe tries to impress the boys by taking them aboard a locomotive. A lunatic hobo arrives and sets the train in motion, which literally runs OVER Farina. Eventually, they leave the rail yard and careen out of control through city and country.

I was enthralled by the location filming of this two-reeler. It gives some interesting glimpses of 1929 Los Angeles. It's also one of the first "Our Gang" comedies with sound, so some of the dialogue is a little hard to understand above the background noise-- but that hardly detracts from the genius of this great short.

This episode is another example of why I feel Farina was the heart and soul of the "Gang." Hal Roach often gave him the most memorable scenes, and for good reason.

Anyone who's been to what passes for a "major city" in . . .

[tadpole-596-918256 · 6/10 · 22 November 2017]

. . . Canadia knows that the urban sidewalks there are clogged with legless men strapped down to some sort of mini-skate boards, selling pencils to passersby in their desperate attempt to survive. How can this be, one wonders, when Canadia has fought in few (if any) wars. As we concluded in our analysis of SMALL TALK--which featured the same deplorable urchins running amok as here during RAILROADIN'--these low-budget shorts bear all the hallmarks of most of the perverse Canadia film offensives. RAILROADIN' begins with SMALL TALK's Orphan Joe suddenly calling an old geezer "Pops," since NAMBLA no doubt originated in Canadia. Then another pervert barges in on two young boys (probably Roy Moore's daddy, before he got deported to Alabama, which serves as Canadia's version of Guantanamo Bay). Chester the Molester starts a train locomotive with these boys aboard--then jumps off, abandoning them! Following this, the Racist Canadiayapper filmmakers run over the only Black kid in sight 18 times with the Runaway Choo-Choo! "Farina" emerges from this sadistic ordeal unscathed (so the diabolical movie crew then eggs him in the face--twice!!). "Inspired" by RAILROADIN', generations of Canadiayapper Youth have tried to ape Farina's Railroad Peril, resulting in all of Canadia's urban centers being choked with double amputee panhandlers selling pencils. (And these unfortunates are considered "the lucky ones" in their Homeland!)

And my vote for best job of parenting in 1929 goes to the father of Joe and Chubby!

[planktonrules · 5/10 · 6 November 2011]

This is the second Our Gang film shot with sound. However, the sound quality is much worse than the first--and it's often tough to hear exactly what the kids are saying. It's a darn shame that the DVD set did NOT include captions--they really needed it on this one.

This film was a bit unusual in that it added a second incredibly obese kid to the mix. In addition to the long-time member of the Gang, Joe Cobb, this film marks the introduction of Chubby Chaney--who plays Joe's brother.

The kids are all playing around the railroad yard (the dynamite factory and acid vats at the nearby chemical plants must have been closed). Joe and Chubby's father is an engineer and with all the railroad noise I had no idea what was being said much of the time. Joe begins bragging and pretends that he knows everything about trains--and even invites some of the kids aboard the engine. However, an evil hobo comes along and deliberately sets the train in motion--and it's soon out of control. At this point, the film gets a bit stupid--and the train keeps nearly killing poor Farina. Who thought all this was funny?! Plus, the special effects were pretty poor--and almost none of this looked very convincing. You'd have to see all this to know what I am talking about here. However, after all these close calls around the rail yard, the train takes off on a trip through the Los Angeles countryside--and they miraculously survived. It's all very diverting but the effects sure could have been improved--even for 1929 they were weak.

The morals of this story seem to be that Joe and Chubby have the worst father in history AND you shouldn't trust crazy hobos! Also, I didn't rate this one any higher as it's essentially a remake of the Our Gang silent film "The Sun Down Limited"--which starred Joe and Mickey Daniels are the INSANE kids to take a train joy-riding.

Our Gang does the Locomotion.

[mark.waltz · 7/10 · 13 November 2019]

Some pretty good effects for an early talkie that screams "All aboard!" for the Little Rascals, speaking on screen for only the second time, and provided plenty of visual action that is quite amusing. Visiting a railroad yard, a bunch of the gang ends up being on a runaway train that heads back and forth for the longest time, with poor Farina's foot stuck in the track so he has to bob up and down over and over until being miraculously picked up by the speeding train. There's not much plot, just a ton of terrific visuals in an experiment of sight, sound and speed that really impresses.

Railroadin' is an interesting second Our Gang talkie

[tavm · 5/10 · 5 October 2014]

This Hal Roach comedy short, Railroadin', is the ninetieth in the "Our Gang/Little Rascals" series and the second talkie. This one is a partial remake of the silent The Sun Down Limited with Joe and Chubby-newcomer Norman Chaney-at the controls this time with Harry and Farina in tow, but not before Farina once again gets himself stuck on the tracks with the train once again almost flattening him several times! Since this was early in the talkie era, the sound seems mostly live except when obvious undercranking is used and there's no music score-which might have helped make this a little more funny-except when "The End" shows on print. As a result, this isn't very funny but it's still interesting to watch especially when the camera dollies across the scenery at a steady speed. So on that note, Railroadin' is worth a look. P.S. These first two talkie shorts had as the series title, "Hal Roach presents His Rascals' Voices".

Poor Short

[Michael_Elliott · 4 November 2008]

Railroadin' (1929)

* 1/2 (out of 4)

The second "Our Gang" short has an adult letting the kids play on the train, which isn't good when a bum starts the train up and the kids get stuck on its alone. Whereas the first short was unfunny but cute this one here is just downright unfunny and in its own way kind of ugly but more on that in a minute. Once again the technical difficulties of the early sound era plays a big part in this short as none of the actors seem that comfortable with sound. It also doesn't help but the sound discs were considered lost for quite sometime and this leaves a lot to be desired in the audio department. The biggest problem is once again the screenplay, which really doesn't have too many funny lines as not much happens. We see the train go back and forth and crash into a few things but none of it is funny. The film also has a rather ugly moment when the train keeps running over Farina who has his foot stuck in the rails. I'm guessing this was meant to be funny back in 1929 but it's comes off quite unpleasant today and that's not even getting into a debate on why this joke was played on the black kid.