IMDb > The Eleventh Year (1928) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Eleventh Year More at IMDbPro »Odinnadtsatyy (original title)

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 3 reviews in total 

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Man And Machine Work Together In A Fruitful Collaboration

6/10
Author: FerdinandVonGalitzien (FerdinandVonGalitzien@gmail.com) from Galiza
22 February 2013

"Odinnadtsatyy" ( The Eleventh Year ) was directed by the documentary maker and film theorist Herr Dziga Vertov in the silent year of 1928 in order to commemorate, not the tenth but the eleventh anniversary of the October revolution ( Germans also very much like to celebrate Oktober but in a very different kind of way… ).

In Herr Vertov's oeuvre there is a special fondness for showing the hard labor of his countrymen in industrial production to strengthen the U.S.S.R. economy and turning their country into a world power. The 11tth anniversary of the Bolshevik revolution was a perfect excuse for Herr Vertov to put in images his artistic recurring allegories and national patriotism.

So consequently in "Odinnadtsatyy" there are a lot of pistons, cylinders and machines that rattle, clatter and whirl, composing a hypnotic industrial symphony that forms part of the score of the construction and modernization of a powerful U.S.R.R.. In some ways this is very repetitive and certainly monotonous as is hard industrial work in real life (At least according to what this Herr Von has heard since German counts really know nothing about such a subject…). Workers are the main actors of the film and we see them laboring in power stations, cooperatives or mines in the Ukraine, all under the inspiring influence of Herr Lenin who is shown in one shot. Man and machine work together in a fruitful collaboration.

"Oddinnadtsatyy" is full of Herr Vertov's characteristic artistic style and brilliant editing, all in the service of shameless propaganda which has the sole purpose of lifting the nationalism of the Soviet people, a goal that certainly is achieved for supporters and followers of the Bolshevik cause, ja wohl!.

And now, if you'll allow me, I must temporarily take my leave because this German Count must celebrate the 100th anniversary of one of his Teutonic and rich heiresses.

Herr Graf Ferdinand Von Galitzien http://ferdinandvongalitzien.blogspot.com

Was the above review useful to you?

More well shot Russian propaganda

4/10
Author: timbeach-03889
25 December 2015

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

How are we supposed to judge propaganda? I watched this with Russian title cards I couldn't understand, so my initial take was of a simple documentary on the working classes of Russia at the time - and to that extent I loved it. Watching a film like this is - a 'city symphony' or a 'film poem' where there is no plot - is like watching a photography portfolio in motion, and just as a quality photography portfolio can hold your attention with the beauty of the craft, so can a film in this genre, and despite watching a 480p version on youtube, 'The Eleventh Year' was still wonderfully composed. Vertov trademarks were apparent - breaking the fourth wall by drawing our attention to the photography of double exposures and many moving camera shots. Water surfaces are imposed on top of towns and people, and workers the same, so their hard work is seen to be towering over the towns. At best this is wonderfully metaphoric, while at others it is tedious experimentation, but at 42 minutes the film is mercifully short, without too much repetition, so it never grated too badly. Of course, in 2015 when it feels like we have already seen everything on screen there is to be seen, certain subjects, particularly the more common such as the flow of water, and the rhythmic mechanical actions of nuts and bolts and machinated wheels, may feel trivial and monotonous, but who knows how they felt at the time? I enjoyed it even more than 'Man With a Movie Camera.'

However the emphasis on the grimy working class, a staple of 1920's Russian propaganda (such as 'Mat', 'The End of St. Petersburg' 'Battleship Potemkin', and 'Zemyla') aroused my suspicions, before the army shots at the end, followed by internet searches to check what my Russian translation couldn't, confirmed them, so that where before the progress from fields, to mines, to factories and eventually to extravagant city buildings felt like an existential musing on the fruits of our labour, they now feel like a well shot advertisement. Was it possible the Russians of that time could make anything that wasn't propaganda?

If there is a message here, it is don't watch films in a language you don't understand, although in this case I'm kinda glad that I did, for I think I enjoyed it much more than I otherwise would have. Points must be deducted for propaganda though.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 7 people found the following review useful:

Dyslexics of the World, Untie!

5/10
Author: boblipton from New York City
15 May 2011

The montage film, put together to celebrate the eleventh anniversary of the October Revolution and the progress made in Russia -- although Russia is never mentioned in the titles, only Socialism -- is a carefully edited series of clips intended to show all the wonderful things that the Soviet Union had produced in the first ten years of its triumph -- although at least a couple of the clips seem to date to 1896 actualities on steelmaking in France, and one dramatic moving crane shot is lifted from the series that Billy Bitzer shot at the Westinghouse Plant in 1905.

I also think that the ending is a bit padded and slow; I would have cut it a couple of minutes earlier to finish on a high point with plenty of camera movement. I suspect that coming in at less than fifty minutes would have gotten someone upset. This was, after all, a feature.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings External reviews Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history