The Lucky Lady (1926) User Reviews

A moderately interesting romantic comedy effort by Raoul Walsh.

[Solo-12 · 5/10 · 22 February 2007]

Princess Antoinette (Nissen) of San Guido, a fictional Monte Carlo which depends on gambling, is forced to wed the unwilling, womanizing Count Ferranzo (Barrymore). This will accomplish two things; keep the monarchy alive and wipe out the Count's 1,500,000 francs debt to the casino. However, the Princess has her own ideas about the marriage and prefers an American visitor to her town (Collier). She disguises herself and lures the Count into a compromising relationship which makes him unsuitable to the Royals. With just a brunette wig, she fools everyone as a seductive alter-ego, and the fact that no one else recognizes her verges on ridiculous. She ultimately runs off with her true love. The story has some charm but it's handled in a fairly clumsy way. No Lubitsch touch here. Fortunately, Walsh would find his true calling in action/adventure movies during the next four decades.

Some Minor Flaws In An Otherwise Mediocre Movie

[boblipton · 5/10 · 10 August 2019]

In one of those casinos masquerading as an independent European country, the board of directors of the casino decides that Princess Greta Nissen must marry Grand Duke Lionel Barrymore. The princess, however, has already met American William Collier Jr. when she broke out of her ladies seminary to attend a burlesque show, then snuck into his car to hitch a ride back. As a result, she's not pleased with the thought of wedding Barrymore, who is a well-known rake. He is agreeing to marriage only because he owes the casino half a million francs. She secures a promise from Prime Minister (or perhaps Chief Croupier) Marc McDermott that if Barrymore fools around with anyone else, she won't have to marry him. So she puts on a wig, which renders her unrecognizable, to captivate her fiance.

Yes, it's as ridiculous as all that, and it's not helped in the least by gliding over the details, so that there is no clear motivation for anything. Of course it's love at first sight for the ingenues. Of course, she has to get married, and to a libertine, because, we are meant to presume, reasons. And of course, once Miss Nissen puts on a dark wig which is either brunette or red-head, depending on which title you read, it renders her absolutely unrecognizable in a nation where her picture is in every post office and her portrait on every postage stamp, bank note and coin.

Sure. For this, Paramount seems to have borrowed Raoul Walsh from Fox Films. I suspect that they offered it to every director on the lot and he rolled his eyes and announced he had B westerns to direct. I suspect it may have been longer, but they knew they had a stinker on their hands and cut it to the bone, leaving the principal point of interest Miss Nissen in what can only be described as a two-tone performance, as a lively young princess, and as a Parisian demi-monde.

A Delightful Movie with Greta Nissen at Her Most Charming!

[JohnHowardReid · 9/10 · 11 April 2010]

A strangely neglected movie that I would have thought capable of more than satisfying current tastes is the 1926 romantic comedy, "The Lucky Lady". Thanks to stunning sets by Hans Deier, gorgeous costumes by Travis Banton and/or Howard Greer, lustrous photography by Victor Milner, accomplished, fast-paced direction by Raoul Walsh, plus a super-lustrous performance by lovely Greta Nissen in the title role, "Lucky Lady" is a winner. Lionel Barrymore and Marc McDermott are also delightfully charismatic. Admittedly, hero William Collier, Jr., as the naive American abroad in the wastes of Monte Carlo (alias San Guido here) is little more than serviceably handsome, but you can't have everything. It's Nissen's movie! And she is wonderful!