Smouldering Fires (1925) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Familiar plot but outstanding performances!
JohnHowardReid30 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Pauline Frederick (Jane Vale), Laura La Plante (Dorothy Vale), Malcolm McGregor (Robert Elliott), Tully Marshall (Scotty), Wanda Hawley (Lucy), Helen Lynch (Kate Brown), George Cooper (Mugsy), Arthur Lake (party guest who dances with Jane), Bert Roach, Bobby Mack, Frank Newburg, Billy Gould, Rolfe Sedan, Jack McDonald, William Orlamond (committee members).

Director: CLARENCE BROWN. Screenplay: Sada Cowan, Howard Higgin, Melville W. Brown. Titles: Dwinelle Benthall. Story: Sada Cowan, Howard Higgin, Margaret Deland. Photography: Jackson Rose. Film editor: Edward Schroeder. Art directors: Leo K. Kuter, E.E. Sheeley. Assistant director: Charles Dorian. Executive producer: Carl Laemmle.

Copyright 25 November 1924 by Universal Pictures. New York opening at the Piccadilly: 30 March 1925. U.S. release: 18 January 1925. 8 reels. 7,356 feet. 80 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: Ageing female factory owner falls in love with one of her young male employees.

NOTES: Re-made by Warner Bros.-First National in 1933 (without acknowledgment) as Female with Ruth Chatterton, George Brent and Ferdinand Gottschalk in the roles here played by Pauline Frederick, Malcolm McGregor and Tully Marshall.

COMMENT: Blessed with outstanding performances from the entire cast and excellent production values including astute direction from Clarence Brown, here's a romantic drama that holds audience interest from first to last, despite its somewhat familiar plot. The acting is both natural and sympathetic and the plot is cleverly augmented with numerous incidents (the dismissal notices that Scotty is always so happy to produce; the showdown on the factory floor; the rope breaking at the cliff edge; Arthur Lake whirling Miss Frederick across the dance floor) that keep our involvement at a consistently high level. In fact, Pauline Frederick is such a magnetic personality, it's impossible to take our eyes from the screen.

OTHER VIEWS: Although she is little-known today, Pauline Frederick was once the most famous actress in the whole world. (By "actress", I mean just that, not "show business personality"). It was a position she achieved by hard work. "People who think the path of a chorus girl is strewn with roses, have a lot to learn," she once declared. "I knew going on the stage would entail hardships. but I now venture to say that a man with a pick and a shovel has a much easier time!"

It was due to her stage reputation, however, that Pauline Frederick was offered the leading role in her first film, The Eternal City (1915). She continued to play the leads in another 56 movies, right up until 1929. In 1931 she graciously accepted a co- starring role for the first time ever in This Modern Age as a personal favor for Joan Crawford and Irving Thalberg at M-G-M. She was billed second to Joan Crawford. For the rest of her 65-movies career, Pauline Frederick generally played the third lead (never less than fourth), and was top-billed in Monogram's Self-Defense (1933).
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A spectacular performance!
ancientnut2 March 2007
This is the first Pauline Frederick movie I have ever seen and, since very few of her films survive, it might be the only one I ever have an opportunity to view. This film changes gradually from a romantic comedy to a romantic tragedy. A very good cast, including Malcolm McGregor, Laura La Plante, and especially Tully Marshall, provides excellent support, but my rating is based on the performance of Ms. Frederick, which is nothing short of breathtaking! I have seen many silent movies and I don't believe I have ever seen an actress achieve the extraordinary emotional range that the 41-year-old Ms. Frederick did in this film. It makes one mourn for the loss of most of her screen work. Very highly recommended.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Clarence Brown is the Real Star!!!
kidboots24 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Pauline Frederick was a noted stage actress who came to films late in her career (she was in her thirties). She played the type of roles that Ruth Chatterton became associated with in the early 30s ("Female" (1933)).

"Be Necessary to Others" and "Let No Man Be Necessary to You" are two mottoes that clearly summarize the way Jane Vale (Pauline Frederick) lives her life. The film opens with a business meeting and Jane, who is 40 years old, unmarried and both President and General Manager of the company her father founded, shows in her stern demeanor and severity of her dress that she has a lack of warmth and a disbelief in the power of love. She fires a man who has drawn a caricature of her kicking Cupid and when a young secretary, she has reprimanded for flirting, says she hopes to have more than a desk to lean on by the time she's 40, Jane fires her as well. Robert Elliott (Malcolm MacGregor) is a production line inspector who shares Jane's zeal for efficiency. They have a confrontation and Robert accuses her of being surrounded by "yes" men - she is just about to sign his dismissal papers but is drawn to something in his manner and ends up giving him a raise.

Jane begins to fall in love with him but Robert feels only gratitude. The office is determined to make something out of it and sexual innuendo runs riot. One man calls their offices "connecting rooms" and a seamstress (pretty Wanda Hawley), who earlier was told off by Robert, changes the label from "Baby Rompers" to "Her Baby's Rompers" and leaves them on his desk. Robert has had enough and loudly proclaims to the office that Jane Vale is to be his wife. Jane is deliriously happy and tries to recapture her lost youth with a series of beauty treatments.

When Dorothy (lovely Laura La Plante) arrives home from college, she is initially cool toward Robert - she thinks he is only after her sister's money but she and Robert gradually fall in love. (Robert only feels a deep friendship for Jane). The wedding goes ahead, Dorothy feels Jane's happiness is all that matters. Jane has all the beauty treatments at her disposal and she is blissfully ignorant of anything but her own happiness. Clouds gather when Dorothy brings some friends over for a party and one of them mistakes Jane for Robert's mother. After an evening of youthful dancing and hijinks, Jane realises it was wrong to marry someone so young - she simply can't keep up. Quite accidentally she realises that Dorothy and Robert love each other and despite her own happiness pretends it is all a mistake and she longs for her freedom, thus paving the way for her sister's happiness.

Clarence Brown bought taste and imagination to this film at a time when he was thought of as a competent director but nothing special. Soon after this he went to MGM and his name became synonymous with style, class and Greta Garbo. "Smouldering Fires" had no plot complications or misunderstandings and Pauline Frederick kept the audience sympathy to the end. Throughout the film to show key scenes, 3 shots were used - usually Jane holding Dorothy and Robert in her arms, the audience being able to tell exactly what each character was thinking. In the pivotal scene where Jane finally learns where Dorothy's affection lies, she is comforting Dorothy, then she sees Robert in the garden. When she calls his name, she sees Dorothy's reaction in the mirror. The last scene, with her fingers to her lips, provides the meaning to her father's motto "Be Necessary to Others" - Jane is going to let the motto be her guide in life as well as business.

The DVD I have is not restored and pretty grainy but it does not detract from the performances or the direction. I still give it 10 out of 10.

Highly, Highly Recommended.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed