The Enchanted Cottage (1924)

Director:

John S. Robertson

Writers:

Gertrude Chase (titles)
Josephine Lovett (writer)

Release Date:

24 March 1924 (USA)

Genre:

Drama

Plot Keywords:

Based On Play

Cast

Richard Barthelmess	...	Oliver Bashforth
May McAvoy	...	Laura Pennington
Ida Waterman	...	Mrs. Smallwood
Alfred Hickman	...	Rupert Smallwood
Florence Short	...	Ethel Bashforth
Marion Coakley	...	Beatrice Vaughn
Holmes Herbert	...	Major Hillgrove (as Holmes E. Herbert)
Ethel Wright	...	Mrs. Minnett
Harry Allen

Runtime:

USA:70 min

Country:

USA

Color:

Black and White

Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1

Sound Mix:

Silent

Filming Locations:

New Jersey, USA

Company:

Inspiration Pictures

Trivia:

A print of this film still exists at the Library of Congress.

Movie Connections:

Version of The Enchanted Cottage (1945)

Barthelmess and McAvoy Shine

This 1924 silent is a gem with a great story remade 20 years later and two tops stars: Richard Barthelmess and May McAvoy.

Barthelmess plays a young man hideously crippled from WW I. All he wants is to be left alone with his bitter thoughts, so he hies away at a seaside cottage. There he has a house keeper, but there's also a homely spinster (McAvoy in makeup) who is a local do-gooder. Neither thinks much about the other. But then his sister (Florence Short) a very masculine and pushy girl decides to come live at the cottage and take charge of her sullen brother's life. He panics and in a weak moment proposes to the homely girl so that they might not be so lonely.

We are told that the cottage is called the "Honeymoon Cottage" but it doesn't mean much until the couple is married and repulses the sister. As they get to know each other they also discover the etched (on a window) names of former lovers dating back hundreds of years.

Each secretly falls in love with the other but it's not until the spirits of former lovers start to appear that the magic of love begins to take place. Suddenly the homely girl becomes beautiful and the crippled man becomes straight and strong. In each other's eyes they become perfect and beautiful.

A blind neighbor (Holmes Herbert) seems to know what's going on and encourages the young couple who become reclusive in their honeymoon love. It's not until the man's family (including the awful sister) come to visit that the spell is broken by their crudeness. But after they leave the shattered couple (now in love) fall back together in their sorrow but wake to a new life together.

Barthelmess may well have been the best all-round actor in silent films, and he had a shot of almost every kind of part. Here he is crippled and sullen; his transformation into a strong and handsome man is quite good. Better is McAvoy's. She goes from a hawk-nose and snaggly-toothed spinster into a beauty. The make-up and special effects are quite good. As the previous reviewer notes, there is a terrific shot of the beautiful couple descending the darkened stairs to meet his family. We see a glimpse of them as they descend and are shocked to see them as their ugly selves as they come into the light of the parlor.

This film is a delicate bit of fantasy (from a play by Arthur Wing Pinero) that meditates on the qualities of love and magic. Are the couple really transformed when they are alone together. Or do they only see what love shows them? The blind man seems to think the transformations are real because he states he's still waiting. But no one else sees the "new" couple. Is beauty then in the eye of the lover?

This is a gem of a film; it's a pity it's so little known.