All the Brothers Were Valiant (1923) -- Lost Silent
Joel Shore ( Malcolm McGregor ) is the last of a long line of seafaring men, his brother Mark having disappeared from the "Nathan Ross" when it was anchored off the Gilbert Islands. Joel is hired as captain of the boat for a three-year run on a whaling vessel, and before sailing he marries his sweetheart, Priscilla Holt ( Billie Dove ). The newly married couple sail off, but the young wife soon becomes bored with life on the boat, and when they catch their first whale, the smell of the boiling blubber makes her sick. While sailing around Cape Horn, Mark Shore ( Lon Chaney ) amazingly swings over the rail of the boat. He tells a thrilling tale of how he drank too much gin while the "Nathan Ross" was docked, and awoke to find the boat gone. He had taken a native girl as his sweetheart, and when some pearl hunters captured her, he climbed aboard their boat and killed one of the men. They set sail on a pearling expedition, and found a huge oyster bed that made them all rich. Mark killed the other two pearl hunters and hid the pearls on a remote island. His native girl was killed by savages on the island, and Mark was forced to flee. Learning that the "Nathan Ross" was in port, he came aboard so that he could go back for the pearls. Joel refuses to help him, keeping his promise not to risk the ship. Soon, the news of the pearls spread, and the crew begins to talk of mutiny. Mark openly makes advances towards Priscilla, and she is shocked that Joel does nothing about it. Eventually, Mark and several of the men take over the ship and plan to go after the pearls. Joel is tied up, but Aaron Burnham ( William H. Orlamond ), the ship's carpenter, remains loyal and helps him escape. Joel demands that the ship be returned to him, and he knocks Mark down with a hard right to the jaw. A terrible fight follows between the mutineers and the loyal crewmen. Mark sides with Joel in the fight and is knocked overboard. Joel dives in trying to save him, but Mark is lost at sea. Order is restored to the ship and Priscilla underlines the first words of Joel's report in the logbook, "All the Brothers Were Valiant."
"Metro has converted Ben Ames Williams' story into a splendid sea picture...It is an attraction that will be enthusiastically received by men, and because of its romantic interest will appeal to many women...Lon Chaney gives the most striking performance of the production. As the bragging husky of the seas he is most convincing and gets a slightly humorous meaning out of his role. The character is a particularly human one."---Moving Picture World
This 1923 adventure/drama/romance, starring Lon Chaney and was produced by Metro Pictures Corporation with filming on locations in San Francisco, California. Sadly it remains a lost silent film.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?