Up 104,354 this week

He Did and He Didn't (I) (1916)

TV-G  |   |  Short, Comedy, Drama  |  30 January 1916 (USA)
Your rating:
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 -/10 X  
Ratings: 6.4/10 from 154 users  
Reviews: 8 user | 3 critic

A doctor irrationally suspects his wife is carrying on an affair with her childhood friend.


(as Roscoe Arbuckle)
0Check in

On Disc

at Amazon

IMDb Picks: April

Visit our IMDb Picks section to see our recommendations of movies and TV shows coming out in April.

User Lists

Related lists from IMDb users

list image
a list of 453 titles
created 05 Sep 2012
a list of 330 titles
created 25 Feb 2013
list image
a list of 1673 titles
created 18 Mar 2013
a list of 883 titles
created 13 Sep 2013
a list of 294 titles
created 07 Nov 2013

Related Items

Connect with IMDb

Share this Rating

Title: He Did and He Didn't (1916)

He Did and He Didn't (1916) on IMDb 6.4/10

Want to share IMDb's rating on your own site? Use the HTML below.

Take The Quiz!

Test your knowledge of He Did and He Didn't.




Complete credited cast:
The Doctor (as Roscoe Arbuckle)
The Doctor's Wife
William Jefferson ...
The Wife's Schoolmate (as Wm. Jefferson)
The Bounding Burglar
Joe Bordeaux ...
The Burglar's Accomplice
Lloyd Peddrick ...
The Butler
Jimmy Bryant ...
The Burglar's Second Accomplice
Gilbert Ely ...
The Cop


A doctor, very much in love with his beautiful wife, comes to suspect that her visiting childhood friend Jack is more than just a friend. Jack's intentions are honorable, but everything he does tends to show his actions in a suspicious light, especially when burglars invade the house and Jack and the wife are caught together in their nightclothes. Written by Jim Beaver <>

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Plot Keywords:

repetition in title | See All (1) »


Short | Comedy | Drama






Release Date:

30 January 1916 (USA)  »

Also Known As:

Love and Lobsters  »

Filming Locations:

Company Credits

Production Co:

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs


(TCM print) (2005)

Sound Mix:



Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


Featured in Hollywood: Single Beds and Double Standards (1980) See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Lobsters and mobsters, but Roscoe is un-shellfish.
22 April 2006 | by (Minffordd, North Wales) – See all my reviews

Several of Roscoe Arbuckle's films have titles which became cruelly ironic in the hindsight of his 1921 trial for manslaughter: notably 'The Life of the Party' and this two-reeler, 'He Did and He Didn't'. There's a famous photograph of Arbuckle in evening dress, gaping in horror as he drops Mabel Normand down a staircase. That photo is a publicity still from 'He Did and He Didn't', though it doesn't actually correspond to any scene in the film as it now exists.

Arbuckle rose to film stardom playing boobs, rubes and bumpkins. By 1916, he had autonomy over his own films and was able to impose some tastefulness. Here, he plays a dignified and wealthy suburban doctor, in a loving marriage to Normand. But then Jack, her handsome beau from high-school days, arrives. There are no 'fat boy' jokes here. Instead, Arbuckle uses underplayed and sensitive acting to compare himself unfavourably to the leaner and manlier Jack. It's clear that Arbuckle's character loves his wife deeply but is (in some unspoken manner) unable to satisfy her, possibly down to sexual impotence. When Jack arrives to stay the weekend, the three of them sit down to a dinner of lobsters -- allegedly a male aphrodisiac -- prompting Mabel to comment that they'll all likely have nightmares.

SPOILERS COMING. Arbuckle (in a car with right-hand drive) is lured to a remote location on a ruse, so that he'll be away when burglars invade his house. It's up to Jack to defend the fair Mabel. Arbuckle returns home, distraught, and then -- believing that his wife has cuckolded him -- he calmly strangles her. This scene is immensely disturbing in its own right, and even more disturbing in the light of Arbuckle's real-life tragedy a few years later.

The payoff: remember those lobsters? Sure enough, it WAS all a nightmare ... and Mabel has remained faithful to her husband. There's a good performance by Rube Miller as Arbuckle's saturnine butler, and Al St John's tumbling skills get a protracted showcase here. 'He Did and He Didn't' is an astonishing film: quite removed from the lowbrow slapstick of Arbuckle's early Keystone efforts, yet still extremely funny. Watching this movie, I deeply regret that Arbuckle's career was so tragically and unfairly terminated just as he was nearing the heights of his talents. I'll rate this fine funny movie 10 out of 10.

7 of 9 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Discuss He Did and He Didn't (1916) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: