The Three Brothers (1915) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Decidedly old-fashioned; well acted, but primitively presented
mmipyle1 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I decided this afternoon to watch a little 2-reeler with Wallace Reid called "The Three Brothers" (1915). Decidedly old-fashioned in many respects, even for 1914 when it was shot, nevertheless, I can see why Wally Reid was so popular in the 1910's. This one is about three brothers in the countryside of Canada who live with their widowed mother. A distant cousin comes to live with them. It is the custom of the country for the eldest to be able to pledge his love and marry before the others. The eldest is Wally Reid. The second brother, an evilly motivated brother, is played by Allan Sears. The third, the youngest, brother is played by William Hinckley. Wally has to go off to sea to make money to be able to take care of his cousin, with whom he indeed falls in love. He leaves, but while he's gone his second brother takes advantage of a fact that his ship has been lost at sea and Wally drowned. Actually, Wally didn't drown and wrote a letter (which is intercepted by his second brother) to that effect. The second brother now tries to take advantage of the cousin, but she rebuffs him and eventually pledges her love to the youngest brother. Wally, now home but not having yet made that known, overhears the pledge from his cousin, then goes off to muse the fact over. The second brother, finding out the situation, actually plans to kill his brother, but Wally thwarts the plan and saves the day, gives his younger brother his blessing, and hopes his second brother can ever forgive himself. The curse of Cain, as Wally calls it. The End.

The acting is very natural and first rate. This was released in January of 1915, Wally's first release of that year. BUT - the presentation, both the camera work and the actor's blocking, is very primitive and just too old-fashioned for most modern viewers. The direction, by Christy Cabanne, is fair at best. This probably was a fine programmer for its day, but it's seen its best day now. Definitely a relic for a silent movie lover's lazy afternoon when there are about 30 minutes to kill.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
A Big Disappointment!
silentmoviefan22 May 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this film this afternoon. I was disappointed. What disappointed me so much? Well, I would have to say the end! Honestly, it did not look like it was finished! I game this film a "2". It only gets a "2" because Wallace Reid is in it and he was a splendid actor. This was back before an unfortunate accident while filming Valley of the Giants (1919) resulted in his being hopelessly hooked on drugs. Mr. Reid made other films that year. Carmen (1915) is way better and The Student Prince of Old Heidelberg (1915) is a bit better (a bit short, too!) In this movie, he plays the oldest of three brothers in what(even though it doesn't come right out and say) is Quebec, since they are referred to as French and references are made to French traditions. The characters also speak French in the title cards. The setting is sort of like the television show "Bonanza", with three brothers. The difference is the presence of "Ma", instead of "Pa" being present and it's not set in the West. Into their lives comes their cousin. When the actress playing the cousin enters the film, she has this great big hat and you can't hardly tell what she looks like. Somehow, the brothers get smitten over her (the pickings must have been slim, then!). Eventually, as in not right away, she has nothing on her head and looks more presentable. One of those French traditions, which their mother reminds them of, is that the oldest brother gets first call on the girl. The Reid character realizes he needs more money and goes off to sea to make his fortune. He heads for the sea to get his fortune. The middle brother, played by an actor named A.D. Sears, decides he wants the cousin and hide Reid's letters from the family. He then talks to the cousin and tells her she's been deserted and she tells him that she doesn't really love the Reid character, she would just marry him out of duty. One problem... Reid has come back from the sea and reaches his family's home in time to hear her say this... He does do something about it, but right after he starts trying to implement his decision, the movie ends! I would say where I got the print I viewed, but the company has apparently gone out of business... This film should have gone out of business with it!
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed