IMDb Polls

Poll: Best portrayal of Sherlock Holmes

Many actors have portrayed the popular detective Sherlock Holmes. Who did the best job at it? Limited to the most popular/prolific movies/series/actors.

Discuss the list here

Results of 5,774 votes:

  1. 1.

    Benedict Cumberbatch

    So far three seasons of "Sherlock"
  2. 2.

    Robert Downey Jr.

    So far two movies; Sherlock Holmes and Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
  3. 3.

    Jeremy Brett

    Four series and seven seasons: "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes", "The Return of Sherlock Holmes", "The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes" and "The Memoirs of Sherlock …

Related Polls

What Greek god do you want to be? They are immortal and exist for many purposes, positive or negative, posses with different powers and personalities that always superior then human or mortals. So, what kind of god do you want to be? …
Dark Thoughts Which of these characters constantly sharing their dark & somber inner monologue with us is your favorite? Discuss here
You're Caught in a Mystery Well, it seems that you accidentally got too deep into something big, and the only way to get out is to get to the bottom of these strange events. The trouble is you're a terrible detective and you ca…
Favorite character with lack of social skills Which of these characters who display a lack of social skills is your favorite? Discuss the list here
Favorite crime-fighting duo? Which of these duos/partnerships that fight against crime is your favorite? Discuss here
Which of these brilliant minds from TV would you rely on to save the Earth? Which of these brilliant minds (MALE humans only) from a television series would you rely on in a crisis to save the world from a global catastrophe? Recruit your brains-over-brawn hero here! This pol…
Favorite acute observationalist? Characters who notice the smallest of details
Favorite TV Eccentric Genius There is sort of a trope for brilliant minds who are 'cloudcuckoolanders'--characters who are heads and shoulders above everybody in their particular sphere of knowledge or work. But when it comes to …
Confessions of a Mad Raving Cynic This is a list of cynical, nihilistic and depressing quotes by pessimistic characters. Which quote do you agree with the most? Vote Here! and Discuss!
You're Stuck in the Middle Ages Good for you. You got out of the Old West and managed to escape the Modern West. Along the way you were able to get more duct tape and replace the broken parts of your time machine. Unfortunately, on…
TV characters with iconic items of clothing ... Which of these TV characters wears the most iconic item of clothing? (listed by characters) Discuss this poll at
Sword-wielding Warriors Which of these sword-wielding movie warriors would you follow into battle? Discuss this poll here
Face-Off: James Bond vs Sherlock Holmes James Bond and Sherlock Holmes, between these two highly intelligent characters from British literature which one is your favorite? Discuss the poll here
The Chosen Ones From this list of fantasy movie "chosen ones", which one do you chose? Discuss here For part II, vote HERE
Movie Characters That Descend into Insanity These characters aren't fully thereself anymore. Which of these characters that have descended into instanity do you feel most sorry for? Discuss here
Colourful Characters Which of these movie characters with a colour in their name is your favourite? Discuss here
Who is Doctor Watson? There have been various depictions of Sherlock Holmes companion Dr. John Watson. Which best describes your perception of the character? (Don't vote for your favorite movie/TV show but for your genera…
I Want an Eternal Life! If you want immortality, how would you get it? Discuss your way here.
Who are you? (TV version) Which of these TV characters gives the most memorable response to that question? You may discuss the poll here. See also: Who are you? (Movie version)
Favorite oft-adapted male literary character from the 19th century A list of male literary characters who first appeared in the 19th century, often adapted in movies. Limited to protagonist and/or title characters. Discuss the list here.