15 March 2013 11:00 PM, PDT | The Guardian - TV News | See recent The Guardian - TV News news »

As The Voice and Bgt returm, we ask music and TV experts whether the format's days are numbered

Whack "slams TV talent shows" into Google and a procession of varied names pops up, each with their own opinion. There's Elton John ("Brain-crippling"); Julie Walters ("People's real vulnerabilities are being exploited"); Des O'Connor ("I don't like people who trample on dreams"); Ne-Yo ("They don't know what it is to bleed"); and Shirley Bassey ("Lives are ruined"). Even Pop Idol winner Will Young insists that talent shows are "cynical and manipulative".

These criticisms have been flung at the format for over a decade, and they routinely bounce off armour-plated behemoths like The X Factor, a show with all the too-big-to-fail swagger of a twatty bank, particularly when they could claim that they were giving unknowns a chance at stardom. But in 2012, both The X Factor's season launch and season finale ratings »

- Peter Robinson

Report a problem



Similar News Items

"American Idol" (2002)
"The X Factor" (2004)
"The Voice" (2011)


IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.

See our NewsDesk partners