Some anniversaries end with a romantic candlelit dinner; others end with a girl learning that her boyfriend has been secretly terrorizing her friends for the past three years. Sadly, Spencer (Troian Bellisario) experienced the latter on the Sept. 22 episode of Pretty Little Liars, as she finally discovered that Toby (Keegan Allen) is actually a member of the “A” team. He may look damn good in a towel, but Toby looks real bad in a hoodie.
He’s been playing Spencer like a fiddle for months, but the second he got sloppy, it was all over. After accidentally dropping a key next to Hanna (Ashley Benson) and leaving his bogus I.D. card for the Radley Sanitarium out in plain sight, Spencer finally confronted him. Even though he didn’t actually respond to her, it was still one