Jane Eyre versions and their ranking...in my oh so Eyre-filled mind!

yes I do pun above.;) As the title says just a ranking of the Jane Eyre films/miniseries I've seen ranked from best(1) to worst (5) Though for me worst isn't necessarily awful.
View:
Log in to copy items to your own lists.
1.
Jane Eyre (2006 Mini-Series)
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 8.4/10 X  
A young governess falls in love with her brooding and complex master. However, his dark past may destroy their relationship forever. (230 mins.)
“ What I like:
Development of Jane and Rochester's relationship and dialogue therein. The only version of the five I've seen where you understand how they come to love eachother, and just how deep that connection is. So many of the great moments between Jane and Rochester and their very revealing conversations are kept true to spirit.

Portrayal of Rochester's Character- his moodiness, obsession and possesiveness with Jane, early sarcasm and cynicism are all best in this one though his look is a little off. Just a LITTLE mind you.

Meeting scene

Portrayal of Sinjin and Sisters- so often this part of the story is rushed over and St. John, Diana, and Mary are very often not given real characters. Here they present them wonderfully.

Reunion scene


Didn't Like:
Adele
Very short portrayal of Jane's Childhood ” - amiNotAwake
 
2.
Jane Eyre (2011)
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.4/10 X  
A mousy governess who softens the heart of her employer soon discovers that he's hiding a terrible secret. (120 mins.)
“ What I like:
Jane as a whole (Character and Look) Mia is an amazing Jane. Captures her passion, restraint, intelligence, understanding, the essence of Jane Eyre

Rochester as a whole (Character and Look)

Proposal Scene (The 'bleeding inwardly' line just wrenches at one's heart)

Wedding Scene and Meeting the Wife

Pleading Scene-Fassbender captured the extremeties in Rochester's character brilliantly. Jane's struggle, yet determination and strength-Mia got it all perfect.

Atmosphere-I truly felt in the novel, at Thornfield.

Non-linear plot-maybe I'm being a little radical but I loved this new form.

Didn't Like:
Brevity of story, background, relationship devolpment ” - amiNotAwake
 
3.
Jane Eyre (1983 Mini-Series)
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 8.2/10 X  
A young governess falls in love with her mysterious employer, but a terrible secret puts their happiness at risk. (239 mins.)
Director: Julian Amyes
“ What I like:
Jane's Look

Grace Poole/Bertha mystery is shown best in this version

Fire Scene - Best of Dalton

Rochester's Pleading - Dalton also did very well in this scene. You truly feel his desperate need for Jane.

Didn't like:

Zelah's performance as Jane
Poor Production ” - amiNotAwake
 
4.
Jane Eyre (1996)
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 6.8/10 X  
Jane Eyre is an orphan cast out as a young girl by her aunt, Mrs. Reed, and sent to be raised in a harsh charity school for girls... (112 mins.)
“ What I like:
Young Jane/ Portrayal of Jane's childhood and the oh so rare inclusion of Ms. Temple

Reunion Scene

Didn't like:
William Hurt as Rochester; he only worked in Rochester's vulnerable moments.
Jane was a ghost of what she should be. ” - amiNotAwake
 
5.
Jane Eyre (1943)
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.6/10 X  
After a harsh childhood, orphan Jane Eyre is hired by Edward Rochester, the brooding lord of a mysterious manor house to care for his young daughter. (97 mins.)
“ People who know me would assume I'd like this version best since I've always been into classic movies.

The BEST part is Jane's childhood. They did an excellent job. Peggy Ann Garner as little Jane is perfection. Little Taylor did well also. Orson Welles was okey-dokey, but I very much did not like Joan Fontaine. Blaaacchh. Bad casting there, bad acting. Never really understood her appeal. Maybe I just need to see her in more films.

Anyways overall okay. Forgettable. ” - amiNotAwake
 
6.
Jane Eyre (1997 TV Movie)
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.2/10 X  
Charlotte Bronte's classic novel is filmed yet again. The story of the Yorkshire orphan who becomes... (108 mins.)
Director: Robert Young
“ Didn't hate this version but overall just fell flat.
Where William Hurt was all vunerability in '96 Ciarian Hinds was all roughness and angst.

I have only seen this one once and it was quite a while ago. Maybe a revisit will joggle my memory and I'll be able to list some good qualities as I did with the others. ” - amiNotAwake