Top Rated "Mystery" Titles
| Rank | Rating | Title | Votes |
| 1. | 8.7 | Rear Window (1954) | 163,703 |
| 2. | 8.7 | The Usual Suspects (1995) | 367,975 |
| 3. | 8.7 | Psycho (1960) | 201,218 |
| 4. | 8.7 | Se7en (1995) | 438,736 |
| 5. | 8.6 | Memento (2000) | 404,827 |
| 6. | 8.6 | North by Northwest (1959) | 122,228 |
| 7. | 8.5 | Citizen Kane (1941) | 176,246 |
| 8. | 8.5 | Vertigo (1958) | 123,478 |
| 9. | 8.5 | The Shining (1980) | 268,673 |
| 10. | 8.5 | The Departed (2006) | 393,612 |
| 11. | 8.5 | To Kill a Mockingbird (1962) | 111,442 |
| 12. | 8.5 | The Third Man (1949) | 65,648 |
| 13. | 8.4 | Rashomon (1950) | 54,049 |
| 14. | 8.4 | Reservoir Dogs (1992) | 305,018 |
| 15. | 8.4 | Chinatown (1974) | 110,515 |
| 16. | 8.4 | Witness for the Prosecution (1957) | 26,148 |
| 17. | 8.4 | The Prestige (2006) | 335,090 |
| 18. | 8.4 | The Green Mile (1999) | 310,992 |
| 19. | 8.4 | L.A. Confidential (1997) | 225,557 |
| 20. | 8.3 | Oldboy (2003) | 152,816 |
| 21. | 8.3 | Rebecca (1940) | 47,255 |
| 22. | 8.3 | The Maltese Falcon (1941) | 66,093 |
| 23. | 8.3 | High and Low (1963) | 10,360 |
| 24. | 8.3 | Diabolique (1955) | 21,510 |
| 25. | 8.2 | Strangers on a Train (1951) | 48,224 |
| 26. | 8.2 | The Secret in Their Eyes (2009) | 49,042 |
| 27. | 8.2 | The Big Sleep (1946) | 37,725 |
| 28. | 8.2 | Le Samouraï (1967) | 15,375 |
| 29. | 8.2 | Fanny and Alexander (1982) | 21,296 |
| 30. | 8.2 | The Sixth Sense (1999) | 350,209 |
| 31. | 8.2 | Black Swan (2010) | 243,602 |
| 32. | 8.2 | The Thing (1982) | 127,319 |
| 33. | 8.1 | The Manchurian Candidate (1962) | 44,072 |
| 34. | 8.1 | Donnie Darko (2001) | 299,250 |
| 35. | 8.1 | Laura (1944) | 18,064 |
| 36. | 8.1 | The Exterminating Angel (1962) | 10,765 |
| 37. | 8.1 | Z (1969) | 10,504 |
| 38. | 8.1 | Dial M for Murder (1954) | 45,826 |
| 39. | 8.1 | Memories of Murder (2003) | 20,161 |
| 40. | 8.1 | Anatomy of a Murder (1959) | 23,428 |
| 41. | 8.1 | Incendies (2010) | 17,866 |
| 42. | 8.1 | Twelve Monkeys (1995) | 238,044 |
| 43. | 8.1 | Sleuth (1972) | 23,759 |
| 44. | 8.1 | Stalker (1979) | 31,773 |
| 45. | 8.1 | Shadow of a Doubt (1943) | 27,352 |
| 46. | 8.1 | Three Colors: Red (1994) | 33,614 |
| 47. | 8.1 | Rope (1948) | 47,382 |
| 48. | 8.1 | Great Expectations (1946) | 11,910 |
| 49. | 8.1 | The Lady Vanishes (1938) | 21,979 |
| 50. | 8.1 | Infernal Affairs (2002) | 49,060 |
Bottom Rated "Mystery" Titles
| Rank | Rating | Title | Votes |
| 1. | 1.3 | The Sobbing Stone (2005) | 301 |
| 2. | 1.3 | The Maize 2: Forever Yours (2006) | 755 |
| 3. | 1.5 | Blood Deep (2005) | 253 |
| 4. | 1.6 | Qerq (2007) | 397 |
| 5. | 1.6 | The Dead Talk Back (1993) | 547 |
| 6. | 1.8 | Flesh Feast (1970) | 374 |
| 7. | 1.8 | Haunted Boat (2005) | 527 |
| 8. | 1.9 | Catalina Caper (1967) | 1,036 |
| 9. | 1.9 | Brigada explosiva: Misión pirata (2008) | 201 |
| 10. | 1.9 | Daddy-O (1958) | 522 |
The formula for calculating the Top Rated 50 Titles gives a true Bayesian estimate:
weighted rating (WR) = (v ÷ (v+m)) × R + (m ÷ (v+m)) × C
where:
for the Top 50, only votes from regular voters are considered.
In order to appear in the Bottom 10 Titles chart the title must have received at least 1000 votes.
company.