| Rank | Rating | Title | Votes |
| 1. | 8.0 | A Christmas Story (1983) | 50,445 |
| 2. | 7.3 | Christmas Vacation (1989) | 29,541 |
| 3. | 8.1 | (500) Days of Summer (2009) | 36,264 |
| 4. | 6.7 | Clueless (1995) | 36,467 |
| 5. | 7.9 | Love Actually (2003) | 89,739 |
| 6. | 6.7 | The Invention of Lying (2009) | 5,976 |
| 7. | 6.8 | Elf (2003) | 39,539 |
| 8. | 7.2 | White Christmas (1954) | 7,002 |
| 9. | 6.5 | He's Just Not That Into You (2009) | 25,729 |
| 10. | 8.5 | Up (2009) | 69,297 |
| 11. | 7.0 | Home Alone (1990) | 72,392 |
| 12. | 6.6 | Extract (2009) | 5,600 |
| 13. | 5.1 | Just Married (2003) | 17,729 |
| 14. | 7.0 | Funny People (2009) | 23,542 |
| 15. | 8.0 | Zombieland (2009) | 42,453 |
| 16. | 5.5 | Couples Retreat (2009) | 5,320 |
| 17. | 7.4 | Julie & Julia (2009) | 11,093 |
| 18. | 5.4 | Jennifer's Body (2009) | 13,211 |
| 19. | 5.7 | Four Christmases (2008) | 11,162 |
| 20. | 7.3 | Bad Santa (2003) | 42,351 |
